Skip to main content
Work with the NEU
There are contradictions in Paul Mason's view of Starmerism
To nobody’s benefit, not even his own, the once-radical commentator Paul Mason is selling Starmer’s timid immobility as somehow left-wing. It won’t work, explains NICK WRIGHT
Paul Mason argues for continued membership of Nato and the IMF, giving full support to Starmer’s non-confrontational style of centrist leadership

WE have become accustomed to the phenomenon by which the literary labour of Paul Mason, with the inevitability of a natural process, gives rise to its own negation.

After acquiring an enthusiasm for Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership of the Labour Party the lapsed Trotskyite — reacting to the disruption of a Labour rally by pro-EU elements — tweeted: “I am sick of these astroturf elitists … it’s all prep for a millionaire funded ‘centrist party’ that will unleash illegal wars, benefit cuts and drive wages to the bottom.”

Months later he was arguing in the New Statesman for a second EU referendum just as the millionaire-funded Change UK centrist party was created precisely to facilitate that very thing.

  • Cut the substantial majority of carbon emissions by 2030 (82 per cent)
  • The creation of one million green jobs (74 per cent)
  • Closing tax loopholes enjoyed by private schools (73 per cent)
  • An increase in income tax for those earning over £80,000 (71 per cent)
  • Renationaliseation of mail, rail, energy and water (67 per cent)
  • The repeal of anti-trade union legislation (64 per cent)
  • Scrapping tuition fees (61 per cent)
  • The extension of full voting rights to all UK residents (61 per cent)
  • The establishment of a publicly owned generic drug company (60.5 per cent)
  • Compensation for the WASPI women (57 per cent)
  • The introduction of maximum pay ratios of 20:1 in the public sector (56 per cent)
  • The aim of a 32-hour working week within a decade (51 per cent)
The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
New hope or not so much? Andy Burnham
Eyes Left / 4 August 2026
4 August 2026

Preferable to Starmer he may be, but there is scant sign of a sharp political break in Burnham’s policies so far — while left challenges aren’t making much of a running either, finds ANDREW MURRAY. How can socialism be put back on the map?

Enrico Berlinguer (left), who was leader of the Italian Communist Party from 1972 to 1984 and (right) French communist leader Fabien Roussel
Eyes Wright / 30 July 2026
30 July 2026

While Italy’s communist tradition remains fragmented and politically marginal, France’s party is attempting to re-establish itself as an independent force rooted in working-class organisation, says NICK WRIGHT

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer meeting a group of people whose lives have been improved as a result of decisions made by the government, in Downing Street, London, before they attend his final Prime Minister's Questions, July 15, 2026
Editorial / 16 July 2026
16 July 2026
RIGHT ANGER, WRONG ANSWER: Faversham’s small anti-migrant demo assembles, Sunday October 5 2025
Features / 9 October 2025
9 October 2025

Once again, our broad-based coalition outnumbered the anti-migrant protest in Faversham, but tackling the sentiment behind this wave of anger requires explaining the real reasons pushing millions into leaving their homelands, argues NICK WRIGHT