Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Poetic polemics address ourselves and others

IRISH poet WB Yeats once observed that “out of the quarrel with others we make rhetoric; out of the quarrel with ourselves we make poetry.”

It’s an unnecessary distinction that feeds into lazy ideas about public versus private, propaganda versus art. On the other hand, it is sometimes hard to find ways of writing that simultaneously address “others” and “ourselves.”

There are brilliant new examples of how to do it, one of them being Martin Thom’s Fair (Infernal Methods, £5), a satirical attack on the DSEI arms fair held in London every year. Its specific target is the selling of weapons to the Saudi government for use in Yemen. Part of the proceeds from the sale of the book is going to the Campaign Against the Arms Trade.

Written in 300 loose rhyming iambic tetrameters, the poem draws on Shelley’s The Mask of Anarchy. Castlereagh, Eldon and Sidmouth may be long gone, but “Murder, Fraud and Anarchy” are still with us, represented now by such loathsome creatures as Liam Fox, Michael Fallon and Amber Rudd who, as Home Secretary, decided to allow only privy counsellors access to the long-awaited report into the external funding of domestic extremism in Britain.

“What would Shelley find to say/Of Murder met with on his way? And what would Hone or Cruickshank do/with this dismal heartless crew?” asksThom.

It’s a clever, witty, memorable and shout-out-loud poem, compelling and ferocious in its depiction of those who make money by selling “the instruments of Hell … Harm to school or hospital/In a hell-sent British shell” … “And in Hate’s train, the Masque of War,/There marches silent cholera/With scythe and drop and staring eyes/And mottled famine on parade.”

Paul Summers’s arise! (Culture Matters, £5) also draws on Shelley’s poem, not least in its title (“Rise like lions after slumber/In unvanquishable number”).

Sponsored by the Durham Miners Association for this year’s Durham Miners’ Gala and, with an introduction by DMA secretary Alan Cummings, 10 per cent of the proceeds of sales of the book are going to help develop its historic building in Durham into a cultural centre.

Over 400 lines long, the poem is written in short, compressed couplets of cold rage at the scoffers who are still announcing the end of history.

“so history is done/the shafts capped,/the breathless heaps/erased or made-over … a broken picket-line/of hunch-backed thistles,/a huddle of poppies/in a fly-tipped fridge.”

But Summers, whose own family were miners in Northumberland, also hears memory “nagging” and “niggling” in our veins, the whispered “yakka” in the genes, the names of seams and pits closed long ago still remembered “like a lyric/in dense pitmatic” and the “stubborn beat” of history “drumming/in our breaking heart.”

The second half of the poem imagines the forward march of Labour renewed, as history begins to “unlearn defeat.” Tradition and memory join the holiday crowds converging on Durham for the Big Meeting.

“hepburn, smillie,/cook & burt,/bickerstaffe, benn,/hopper & fynes … they join the ranks/of our procession … & so we march, to durham town/for the many/not the few./to build Jerusalem anew./history is done,/the cynics bark,/they do not hear it/singing through the dark … & so we march/& so we march /and so we march.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
sausages
Books / 18 July 2025
18 July 2025

ANDY CROFT rallies poets to the impossible task of speaking truth to a tin-eared politician

Culture / 30 October 2022
30 October 2022
New titles from Fran Lock, Richard Skinner, Tara Bergin and Mark A Murphy
21st Century Poetry / 25 September 2022
25 September 2022
New titles from Kurdish poet İlhan Sami Comak and Volker Braun, one of Germany’s most important writers
21st century poetry / 26 August 2022
26 August 2022
New collections from Neil Fulwood, Kevin Higgins, Clare Saponia, Nora Blascsok and Peter Godfrey
Similar stories
Attila the Stockbroker Diary / 11 July 2025
11 July 2025

Warming up for his Durham gig, the bard pays attention to the niceties of language

Alan Mardghum
Durham Miners’ Gala 2025 / 11 July 2025
11 July 2025

Durham Miners’ Association general secretary ALAN MARDGHUM speaks to Ben Chacko ahead of Gala Day 2025

Band 2025
Features / 26 June 2025
26 June 2025

MOLLIE BROWN reports on this year’s festival in honour of the ‘seven men of Jarrow’ deported to Australia for union activity 193 years ago

Poetry review / 19 November 2024
19 November 2024
JAN WOOLF relishes a book of poetry that deploys the energy of political struggle, rooted in post-war working class history and culture