Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
A necessary meditation on the corrosiveness of fascism
MARY CONWAY applauds the timely restaging of a play premiered to world-wide acclaim in 1981
REVELATORY POWER: (L to R) Elliot Levey, David Tennant and Sharon Small

Good
Harold Pinter Theatre

 

IT’S Germany 1933; the Nazis have exploded into power; Jewish religious practices are outlawed and public conversation is peppered with anti-Jewish rhetoric.

Euthanasia for the infirm is openly discussed; Hitler’s cabinet have suspended the right to protest, and the world is about to be rocked to its foundations by one fanatical man and one uncompromising idea. What would you do if you were there?

CP Taylor’s Good tells of Halder: a clever, free-spirited, civilised, self-confessed liberal who sees himself as — yes — good. Caught up in the march of Nazism and living in Frankfurt, he turns to his own even-handed intelligence to make sense of the prevailing politics.

As the play unfolds, we see how a rational, well-meaning person can be seduced into — at best — folly and — at worst — a self-induced oblivion and denial of a shocking and degrading reality.

The play premiered in 1981 to world-wide acclaim. Times were different then and Nazism was widely regarded as an awful aberration from which we had all learnt and would continue to learn.

In 2022, Dominic Cooke’s superb new production lands in a different space. Now, the world is in turmoil and dangerous populist movements with crazy bids for power challenge our sanity. Suddenly, this timely revival of the play captures a new terror.

Reason, it shows us, is not after all our saviour. Madness can be vindicated if upheld by logic. And moral judgement can be swept away by a surge of eager argument. The current applicability of this work chills the blood.

David Tennant is simply magnificent as Halder. His slender frame emanates, variously: respectability and refinement, fragility, gentleness and kindness, and a sort of “I-wouldn’t-hurt-a-fly” reassurance. Only, when he dons that uniform — boy! — is he the stuff of nightmares!  

Throughout the drama, flaws in Halder’s make-up ripple to the surface, even as he basks in beautiful music or patiently eases his dementia-beset mother into a space she can recognise.

The word “love,” which he uses often, he intones on such a flat and expressionless note that it jars even as it hits the air, and every tilt of his head betrays his hollow centre. This is a performance of revelatory power … as are those of Elliot Levy and Sharon Small who play the range of remaining, vital parts.

As these two actors switch in a heartbeat from one to another of those who share Halder’s life, they exhibit not only a mesmerising acting masterclass but also the image of real people who fade in and out of Halder’s peripheral vision like dispensable adjuncts to his own clear mental path.

Even his wife sinks from high definition to annihilation as her place in his mind fades and his focus turns elsewhere.

Vicki Mortimer’s stark and disturbing set claws at the unconscious like an atrocity glimpsed but brushed away, and director Cooke steers us to a conclusion that lands like an axe in the head.

As Tennant quietly soars, this all-time classic lodges within us, never to let us go.

Runs until December 24 2922. Box office: 03330 096 690, www.atgtickets.com

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
NUANCED AND COMMANDING: Bessie Carter as Vivie Warren) and Imelda Staunton as Mrs Kitty Warren / Pic: Johan Persson
Theatre review / 25 May 2025
25 May 2025

MARY CONWAY recommends a play that some will find more discursive than eventful but one in which the characters glow

The cast in Regarding Shelley / Pic: Upstairs at the Gatehouse
Theatre / 23 May 2025
23 May 2025

MARY CONWAY is disappointed by a play that presents Shelley as polite and conventional man who lives a chocolate box, cottagey life

5ht
Theatre review / 21 May 2025
21 May 2025

MARY CONWAY is stirred by a play that explores masculinity every bit as much as it penetrates addiction

deal
Theatre review / 14 May 2025
14 May 2025

In this production of David Mamet’s play, MARY CONWAY misses the essence of cruelty that is at the heart of the American deal

Similar stories
LOOKING FOR JUSTICE: David Shields as Jacob Dunne in Punch
Theatre Review / 10 March 2025
10 March 2025
MARY CONWAY admires an accomplished drama that explores the consequences of a fatal punch on a desolate housing estate
RAVISSANT! 12. Romola Garai, Gina McKee, Deborah Findlay, Ha
Theatre review / 7 February 2025
7 February 2025
MARY CONWAY recommends a beautifully judged performance that shines a light on the experience of all female war babies and boomers
MASSIVELY RELEVANT: The company in Cable Street
Best of 2024 / 18 December 2024
18 December 2024
A nervous year, showing that the theatre, like the world, stands on a precipice and seems uncertain where to jump
CAMPUS ACTIVISM: Phoebe Campbell in Alma Mater
Theatre review / 18 July 2024
18 July 2024
MARY CONWAY evaluates a polemical play whose actors, rather than the writer, introduce the humanity and the light and shade