Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Garbage, O2 Academy, Leeds
Post-gothic pleasures from masters of rock, electronica and grunge
Engaging: Shirley Manson

“THIS is the apocalypse,” warns Shirley Manson on the song No Horses and the starkness of that sentiment is undercut by a driving beat and backwards guitar, making it the perfect virtual soundtrack for Extinction Rebellion, staging a protest across town in an attempt to get the government to avert climate Armageddon.

It’s one of the few timely interventions by Garbage during their first Leeds gig for 20 years for, as futuristic as their fusion of industrial rock, electronic music and grunge sounded when they released their eponymous debut album in 1995, the US-British quartet have never really embraced change.

Their distinctive post-gothic sound is both their biggest asset and noose, surviving even the absence of indisposed producer and percussionist Butch Vig, replaced on this tour by Matt Walker. Wisely, they acknowledge that double-edged sword with an 18-song set tipped towards the nostalgia of their early albums.

With no new material to promote, this gig is something of a return to the 20th-anniversary celebration of 1998’s Version 2.0, and it’s hard to resist.

Opening track Control is a blast of punk energy not unlike a pop savvy The Prodigy while on #1 Crush, Manson employs her contralto snarl to alternatively seduce and terrorise.

An engaging frontwoman throughout, she circles the stage with an undercut shock of pink hair while preaching the value of staying curious and protecting one another.

Despite a technical glitch — the show pauses at one point while stage hands try and fix it  — she remains in strong voice throughout. The band slyly acknowledge their influences, with the rock-driven Wicked Ways successfully seguing into Depeche Mode’s Personal Jesus and Special extends its interpolation of The Pretenders Talk Of The Town with an additional verse from the original track.

The band break out of their characteristic sound on closing number Even Though Our Love Is Doomed, which taking their trademark style and slows it down to the ominous, melancholy pace of a Portishead.

Drawn from latest album Strange Little Birds, it suggests that change could be afoot for the band after all.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
tambo
Theatre review / 16 May 2025
16 May 2025

SUSAN DARLINGTON is bowled over by an outstanding play about the past, present and future of race and identity in the US

Jonathan Hanks in A Christmas Carol
Theatre Review / 23 December 2024
23 December 2024
SUSAN DARLINGTON enjoys, with minor reservations, the Northern Ballet’s revival of its 1992 classic
Tristan Sturrock and Katy Owen in Emma Rice’s Blue Beard
Theatre review / 6 March 2024
6 March 2024
SUSAN DARLINGTON revels in an exhilarating adaptation of the gruesome fairytale that invokes the real-life horror of women lost to male violence
(L to R) Eddie Ahrens, Rachel Hammond, Hannah Baker and Harv
Theatre Review / 23 May 2023
23 May 2023
SUSAN DARLINGTON is disappointed by a show that aims to highlight misogyny within the police but fails to arrest the audience's attention
Similar stories
sky
Album Review / 12 May 2025
12 May 2025

SIMON DUFF recommends a new album from renowned composer and oud player Anour Brahem.

Steve Knightley
Music / 15 April 2025
15 April 2025

STEVE JOHNSON, CHRIS SEARLE and TONY BURKE review new releases from Steve Knightley, Jupiter & Okwess, Jason Palmer, Lisa Knapp and Gerry Driver, Kin'Gongolo Kiniata, Ingrid Laubrock/Tom Rainey, Dan Sealey, Simin Tande, PAZ

Album reviews / 11 November 2024
11 November 2024
New releases from Propaganda, David Gilmour and Jon Hopkins
The Breeders, Cincinnati, Ohio, April 28 2018
Gig review / 1 July 2024
1 July 2024
SUSAN DARLINGTON encounters the fuzzy charm of a female band that is being rediscovered by Gen Z