Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Melting Pot the crucible of a dramatic dud
Mayer Wakefield reviews THE MELTING POT at Finborough Theatre, London

THE Melting Pot had not been seen before now on a British stage in almost 80 years. So it's somewhat curious that Max Elton's production opens with an introductory letter to then US president Theodore Roosevelt from its author Israel Zangwill thanking him for praising his work.

It's easy to see why Roosevelt liked it. At points, Zangwill's 1908 play projects an almost propaganda-like view of the US as “God’s crucible in which all the races can combine” — thus its protagonist and tormented composer David Quixano (Steffan Cennydd).

What's curious about Elton's decision is that, along with a series of additional segments of narration, it adds nothing to what is already a rather transparent play. Typical of the period, Zangwill leaves little to the imagination as he details the Romeo and Juliet-like tale of two young Russian immigrants recently arrived in New York.
Drawn together by a love of music, they are estranged by faith and history. David, his uncle Mendel (Peter Marinker) and grandmother are “sea-tossed wanderers” who have fled the brutal Kishinev pogroms, while Vera (Whoopie van Raam) has deserted her revolutionary youth, having been expelled to Siberia.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
STAND OUT SONGS: The company in full swing / Pic Helen Murray
Theatre review / 12 September 2025
12 September 2025

MAYER WAKEFIELD recommends a musical ‘love letter’ to black power activists of the 1970s

Urielle Klein-Mekongo (right) rehearsing with Rochelle Rose / Pic: Ali Painter/Brixton
Culture / 2 September 2025
2 September 2025

MAYER WAKEFIELD speaks to Urielle Klein-Mekongo about activism, musical inspiration and the black British experience

BRIXTON
Theatre review / 29 July 2025
29 July 2025

MAYER WAKEFIELD is swept up by the tale of the south London venue where music forged alliances across race, class and identity

inter alia
Theatre review / 28 July 2025
28 July 2025

MAYER WAKEFIELD applauds Rosamund Pike’s punchy and tragic portrayal of a multi-tasking mother and high court judge

Similar stories
A demonstrator holds a distressed American flag and a sign reading
United States / 16 June 2025
16 June 2025
flam
Dance / 30 May 2025
30 May 2025

PETER MASON is wowed (and a little baffled) by the undeniably ballet-like grace of flamenco

NUANCED AND COMMANDING: Bessie Carter as Vivie Warren) and Imelda Staunton as Mrs Kitty Warren / Pic: Johan Persson
Theatre review / 25 May 2025
25 May 2025

MARY CONWAY recommends a play that some will find more discursive than eventful but one in which the characters glow

Terrors
Theatre review / 16 May 2025
16 May 2025

SIMON PARSONS is gripped by a psychological thriller that questions the the power of the state over vulnerable individuals