Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Melting Pot the crucible of a dramatic dud
Mayer Wakefield reviews THE MELTING POT at Finborough Theatre, London

THE Melting Pot had not been seen before now on a British stage in almost 80 years. So it's somewhat curious that Max Elton's production opens with an introductory letter to then US president Theodore Roosevelt from its author Israel Zangwill thanking him for praising his work.

It's easy to see why Roosevelt liked it. At points, Zangwill's 1908 play projects an almost propaganda-like view of the US as “God’s crucible in which all the races can combine” — thus its protagonist and tormented composer David Quixano (Steffan Cennydd).

What's curious about Elton's decision is that, along with a series of additional segments of narration, it adds nothing to what is already a rather transparent play. Typical of the period, Zangwill leaves little to the imagination as he details the Romeo and Juliet-like tale of two young Russian immigrants recently arrived in New York.
Drawn together by a love of music, they are estranged by faith and history. David, his uncle Mendel (Peter Marinker) and grandmother are “sea-tossed wanderers” who have fled the brutal Kishinev pogroms, while Vera (Whoopie van Raam) has deserted her revolutionary youth, having been expelled to Siberia.

She is instantly drawn to the virtuoso violinist who has come to teach at the settlement house for refugees in which she works until she discovers that “the wonderful boy is a Jew.” Yet rampant anti-semitism cannot stop David's talents from reaching an audience, nor prevent their passions from bubbling over. But the demons of their pasts take much, wildly melodramatic, overcoming.

The eight-strong cast give it their best shot, with Alexander Gatehouse and Hayward B Morse in particular both producing very shrewd turns.

But they cannot overcome the play's antiquated nature. As a historical document, The Melting Pot provides a very necessary reminder of the rich US history of immigration and the prejudice that accompanied it.

Yet, as a drama, it couldn't be much more formulaic.

The Melting Pot runs until December 19, box office: finboroughtheatre.co.uk

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
cockfosters
Theatre review / 6 May 2025
6 May 2025

MAYER WAKEFIELD laments the lack of audience interaction and social diversity in a musical drama set on London’s Underground

(L to R) Arian Nik as Samir, Shazia Nicholls as Faiza) Sabrina Sandhu as Harleen
Culture / 15 April 2025
15 April 2025
MAYER WAKEFIELD has reservations about the direction of a play centered on a DVLA re-training session for three British-Pakistani motorists
AWKWARD HOMOGENISING OF RCIAL GROUPS: Gershwyn Eustache Jnr
Theatre Review / 3 March 2025
3 March 2025
MAYER WAKEFIELD wonders why this 1978 drama merits a revival despite demonstrating that the underlying theme of racism in the UK remains relevant
(L) Playwright Richard Bean; (R) John Hollingworth as Donald
Interview / 5 November 2024
5 November 2024
MAYER WAKEFIELD speaks to playwright Richard Bean about his new play Reykjavik that depicts the exploitation of the Hull-based “far-fleet” trawlermen
Similar stories
flam
Dance / 30 May 2025
30 May 2025

PETER MASON is wowed (and a little baffled) by the undeniably ballet-like grace of flamenco

NUANCED AND COMMANDING: Bessie Carter as Vivie Warren) and Imelda Staunton as Mrs Kitty Warren / Pic: Johan Persson
Theatre review / 25 May 2025
25 May 2025

MARY CONWAY recommends a play that some will find more discursive than eventful but one in which the characters glow

Terrors
Theatre review / 16 May 2025
16 May 2025

SIMON PARSONS is gripped by a psychological thriller that questions the the power of the state over vulnerable individuals

RAW POSSESSIVENESS: Jemma Carlton, Dario Coates and Sophie W
Theatre Review / 19 September 2024
19 September 2024
MARY CONWAY marvels at the totally engrossing revival of a little-known classic that speaks volumes to interpersonal relationships today