Skip to main content
NEU Senior Regional Support Officer
McDonnell v Creasy – who is right?
Should Labour renationalise PFI projects or levy a windfall tax? SOLOMON HUGHES looks to the Blair years for the answer
Windfall tax: Stella Creasy

WHAT should a Labour government do about the private finance initiative (PFI), the privatisation scheme squeezing cash from schools and hospitals? Shadow chancellor John McDonnell says bring the deals back in-house, through nationalisation or negotiation.

But Walthamstow Labour MP Stella Creasy has an alternative plan — a windfall tax. Which is right?

PFI schemes ask private consortiums to build and run hospitals or schools charging the government the cost of running the building for 25-30 years.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
A piper walks the platform alongside the Avanti West Coast Class 390 EMU train as it arrives at Glasgow Central Station from London Euston, failing to break the 36-year-old record for the fastest train journey between London and Glasgow, June 17, 2021
Railways / 8 May 2025
8 May 2025

Our groundbreaking report reveals how private rail companies are bleeding millions from public coffers through exploitative leasing practices — but we have the solutions, writes Aslef Scottish organiser KEVIN LINDSAY  

Aslef general secretary Mick Whelan (centre) on the picket l
Features / 22 February 2025
22 February 2025
Aslef general secretary MICK WHELAN speaks to Ben Chacko about rail renationalisation, the Employment Rights Bill and why we shouldn’t write off this Labour government
A teacher and students in a classroom
Features / 20 February 2025
20 February 2025
SOLOMON HUGHES probes the finances of a phoney ‘charity’ pushing the free schools and academies agenda
A general view of a central heating thermostat
Editorial: / 20 February 2025
20 February 2025