Skip to main content
A fortune out of spent pennies
MARIA DUARTE is intrigued by the fascinating tale of a Czech herbal healer who diagnosed his patients by examining their urine
OUTSTANDING: Ivan Trojan in Charlatan

Charlatan (15)
Directed by Agnieszka Holland 
⭑⭑⭑


DUBBED the “oracle of urine,” this fascinating and complex drama set in the 1950s is based on the little known but real-life story of Czech herbal healer Jan Mikolasek, who could diagnose people’s ailments just by looking at their pee. 

 

 

 

Shot in a highly artistic, almost reverential way it makes for gross yet strangely enthralling viewing as Mikolasek (an outstanding Ivan Trojan) holds glass bottles full of his patients’ urine up to the natural light and examines them.

Mikolasek was a celebrated and devout healer who apparently treated several million people — ranging from the poor to Czechoslovakia’s Communist leaders and high-ranking Nazi officials during the German occupation.

Director Agnieszka Holland’s compelling film chronicles the rise and fall of this unconventional but unbelievably gifted medicine man, whose unorthodox methods made him both rich and famous through the course of three different regimes and two world wars.

It also explores his battle with inner demons and his dark side through flashbacks to his youth (his younger self is played by Trojan’s son Josef) his violent and sadistic streak is revealed.

There are also his struggles with his sexuality as he conducts a secret and passionate affair with his married assistant Frantisek Palko (Juraj Loj) — the only person who could reach him emotionally — which results in him praying for redemption at the rocky feet of a crucified Christ. 

There is no sense of the passing of time or of location and unfortunately the film does not provide any critique of Mikolasek, who did whatever it took to survive and continue his work treating sick patients, regardless of their background or politics.

Hounded by the Communist authorities, who were suspicious of him and his success, the film ends on a powerful and shocking note which speaks volumes about the man. It also gives you a surprising insight into urology.

Available on demand.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
hallow
Film of the week / 15 May 2025
15 May 2025

MARIA DUARTE is gripped by a tense drama set almost entirely in a car as distressed parents try to rescue their wayward daughter

Treading Water / Pic: IMDb
Film of the week / 24 April 2025
24 April 2025

MARIA DUARTE recommends a tough love story that unfolds among mental health issues, drug addiction and inadequate housing

THE PERILS OF INTERNET DATING: (L) Ruaridh Mollica in Sebast
Cinema / 3 April 2025
3 April 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Sebastian, Four Mothers, Restless, and The Most Precious of Cargoes
YOU CAN TAKE THE BOY OUT OF PORT TALBOT, BUT: Toby Jones and
Film of the week / 3 April 2025
3 April 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE recommends a drama that explores the formative years of Richard Burton’s life
Similar stories
STUNNING: Ethan Herisse and Brandon Turner in Nickel Boys
Cinema / 10 January 2025
10 January 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Nickel Boys, Bank of Dave 2: The Loan Ranger, Babygirl, and Maria
ANTICOLONIALIST IMPROVISATION: Ambroise Boimbo, a Congolese
Film of the Week: / 14 November 2024
14 November 2024
MARIA DUARTE recommends an exploration of the way famous black jazz musicians were used as camouflage in the US plot to assassinate Lumumba
LAS VEGAS HERE WE COME: Mark Eidelshtein and Mikey Madison,
Cinema / 31 October 2024
31 October 2024
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Anora, Super/Man: The Christopher Reeve Story, Blitz, and Heretic
PAWNS IN A BRUTAL GAME: Jalal Altawil in Green Border
Cinema / 20 June 2024
20 June 2024
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Green Border, Fancy Dance, Before Dawn and The Exorcism