Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Bereft of insight into Chinese culture and politics
MARY CONWAY is disappointed by a production that panders – if inadvertently – to Western prejudice against China
A JOY TO WATCH: (l-r) Gabby Wong (Lan Ping, Jiang Qing) and Millicent Wong (Li Lin, Sun Weishi

Shanghai Dolls
Kiln, Kilburn


THERE should be so much to recommend in this new two-hander which premieres at the Kiln.

For a start the context is rarely explored in this country and introduces ideas that are both weighty and engrossing. Secondly, the production quality is both confident and slick. And lastly, the two female performers are a joy to watch.

Amy Ng’s play, however, is overloaded and often impenetrable for this audience.   

The story is of two women living in China who meet and make friends in 1935. One (Lan Ping) is a passionate, aspiring actress while the other (Li Lin, daughter of an assassinated communist rebel) appears to be down on her luck.

The setting is a rehearsal room in the headquarters of the League of Left-Wing Dramatists where Lan Ping is preparing for an audition. The two women very awkwardly make friends, then proceed through various stages of their lives, culminating in 1991.

When the two first meet, they personify what turn out to be the two conflicting devotions of the play: artistic freedom versus obedience to The Party.

“The Party” of course refers to the Chinese Communist Party while “artistic freedom” is exemplified here through the works of Ibsen and Chekhov. In particular, Ibsen’s A Doll’s House is Lan Pang’s joy, its main character, Nora, being her go-to role.

The problem is the audience must boast more than a passing knowledge of both A Doll’s House and of the life and times of China under the leadership of Mao Zedong to keep up. And this can’t be guaranteed.

When Li Lin first talks of her loyalty to The Party, the concept is sprung upon us as empty words. With no background or conceptualisation offered, single-minded party loyalty of this intensity is inevitably strange to a British audience steeped in liberal individualism. Consequently, the play panders – if inadvertently – to Western prejudice against China, presenting the country’s political construct as an unqualified totalitarian and oppressive regime.

Also, the action on stage has the disadvantage of being upstaged by the much more thrilling drama taking place offstage. Consequently, as the women exchange party loyalty for personal expression and vice versa, their relationship becomes less absorbing than the activities of the dominant men they talk endlessly about, but who never come alive for us.

And by the time the two protagonists change their names and Lan Ping becomes Jiang Qing, third wife of Chairman Mao, they have all but lost their audience and squandered the chance to bring this particular revolutionary history to life.

Actors Gabi Wong (Lan Ping/Jiang Qing and Millicent Wong (Li Lin/Sun Weishi) perform with immense panache; Katie Posner (artistic director of Paines Plough who co-produce) directs in a manner worthy of greatness; and the projected news items of the time heighten the sense of a world on the move.  But the insistence of this play on prioritising a not-very-interesting relationship over the major drama taking place in parallel, is unforgiveable.

Insights into Chinese culture and politics are hugely welcome and necessary. But this is an opportunity missed.

Until May 10 2025. Box office 020 7328 1000, https://kilntheatre.com/whats-on/

 

 

 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
NUANCED AND COMMANDING: Bessie Carter as Vivie Warren) and Imelda Staunton as Mrs Kitty Warren / Pic: Johan Persson
Theatre review / 25 May 2025
25 May 2025

MARY CONWAY recommends a play that some will find more discursive than eventful but one in which the characters glow

The cast in Regarding Shelley / Pic: Upstairs at the Gatehouse
Theatre / 23 May 2025
23 May 2025

MARY CONWAY is disappointed by a play that presents Shelley as polite and conventional man who lives a chocolate box, cottagey life

5ht
Theatre review / 21 May 2025
21 May 2025

MARY CONWAY is stirred by a play that explores masculinity every bit as much as it penetrates addiction

deal
Theatre review / 14 May 2025
14 May 2025

In this production of David Mamet’s play, MARY CONWAY misses the essence of cruelty that is at the heart of the American deal

Similar stories
dealers
Theatre Review / 30 April 2025
30 April 2025

MARY CONWAY applauds the revival of a tense, and extremely funny, study of men, money and playing cards

COMPLEX INNER LIVES: The cast of The Lonely Londoners
Theatre Review / 20 January 2025
20 January 2025
MARY CONWAY applauds a brilliant theatrical adaptation of Sam Selvon’s classic 1950s novel of oppression, betrayal and resilience
DEADLY DYNASTICS: Mark Bonnar, Steffan Rhodri, and Stanley M
Theatre Review / 12 December 2024
12 December 2024
MARY CONWAY applauds a worthy revival of the US 1939 classic drama that studies the dehumanising consequences of affluence
CAMPUS ACTIVISM: Phoebe Campbell in Alma Mater
Theatre review / 18 July 2024
18 July 2024
MARY CONWAY evaluates a polemical play whose actors, rather than the writer, introduce the humanity and the light and shade