Skip to main content
Unity supplement
Whoever takes the White House, it's bad news for the working class
Democratic presidential candidate former Vice President Joe Biden speaks to supporters

WE don't know with any certainty which representative of the contending factions in the US ruling class will be head of state for the next four years and thus commander-in-chief of a military force that is larger than its biggest rivals combined.

This question matters greatly to people in the US who are the victims of a mismanaged, even sabotaged, public-health response to the Covid-19 crisis, who face runaway unemployment, continuing racist violence, a renewed assault on their union rights, civil liberties and women's reproductive rights and a sordid system of migration controls that leaves tens of millions in precarious and low-paid jobs subject to arrest and deportation. And voteless.

It matters less to billions of people throughout the world for whom the choice of which imperialist warmonger resides in the White House make little difference to the way in which the US affects their daily lives.

Whether they live in a Latin American barrio, a bombed out Middle-Eastern village or scratch a living from a scorched patch of African savannah the fine distinctions that appear so great to the liberal commentariat in the western press appear trivial.

The liberal consensus about US democracy and the ridiculous rhetoric about this imperial behomoth being the “leader of the free world” looks even more shaky as Trump insists that before the vote is counted he has won, that not every vote can be counted and if it is it is thus fraudulent.

As this election demonstrates, despite the illusions that liberals harbour about US democracy, the presidential electoral system – devised originally to provide a firewall to protect slavery – is not designed to give a perfect expression of the popular will.

What is distinctive about this, and the previous election, is strikingly similar to the situation in our country.

The binary nature of the political system is breaking down under the impact of the structural crises of the capitalist system and the consequent divisions in the ruling class.

In both Britain and the US, elements in capital have struck out to assert class interests that depart from the priorities the biggest sections of monopoly capital regard as inviolable. In doing so they have sought, with some success, to win over more working people than traditionally align themselves with any section of the ruling class.

The US election turns on the working class in mid-western industrial states that voted twice for Obama on the expectation of a change that did not come — and opted for Trump last time because his rhetoric on jobs and incomes resonated more than did Clinton's neoliberal class arrogance.

Julius Nyerere, the first president of independent Tanzania, is said to have remarked that the US was, like his own, a single-party state, “but with typical American extravagance it has two of them”.

The two capitalist parties of the North American bourgeoisie are shape-shifting creatures that, as do all parties, reflect the way in which capital reorganises production and thus social life.

Workers’ jobs are outsourced to low-wage economies and sacrificed to Wall Street and the City of London and this has changed the ground on which class and political struggle is conducted.

In both the US and in Britain capital temporarily set aside its own divisions and asserted its corporate and ideological power to marginalise the challenges that Sanders and Corbyn both represented.

On both sides of the water the prospects for the left depend critically on the re-entry of the working class into politics in its own interest and not as the auxiliaries of either tendency in the ruling class.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Similar stories
Jack Murillo, a Marine veteran, holds a sign in front of law enforcement guarding a federal building on Tuesday, June 17, 2025, in Los Angeles
Features / 19 June 2025
19 June 2025

There is no doubt that Trump’s regime is a right-wing one, but the clash between the state apparatus and the national and local government is a good example of what any future left-wing formation will face here in Britain, writes NICK WRIGHT

US President Donald Trump gestures to the crowd as he depart
Eyes Left / 16 April 2025
16 April 2025
ANDREW MURRAY casts an eye over past upheavals and asks whether the left can find a fire escape before the world goes up in flames
A man stands in front of the logo at the far-right AfD party
Features / 27 February 2025
27 February 2025
In the recent federal elections the far-right AfD was able to reach sections of the working class on issues over which the left is divided and unable to articulate a coherent position, a situation that is replicated in a number of other European countries, argues NICK WRIGHT
SHOWMEN: Donald Trump
and JD Vance clown for the
crowd using
Features / 23 January 2025
23 January 2025
Corporate power would have stayed intact whether Trump or Harris won, and the Palestine genocide is endorsed by both ‘sides’ of mainstream politics — what we need instead is real, open leftism, argues ROGER McKENZIE