Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Woes of a whistleblower
A new documentary details the trials and tribulations of Chelsea Manning — and they're still not over, says MARIA DUARTE

XY Chelsea (15)
Directed by Tim Travers Hawkins

“IF YOU had free rein over classified networks and you saw incredible things, awful things. What would you do?”

This is one of the most poignant questions explored in this eye-opening look at the life and career of whistleblower Chelsea Manning, a trans woman soldier in the US army who, having witnessed such “awful things,” instigated the largest leak of secrets in US history.

She disclosed 750,000 documents to WikiLeaks which included the video, which went viral, of US soldiers killing 12 Iraqi civilians, including two Reuters journalists, in Baghdad.

Manning was sentenced in 2010 to 35 years in an all-male military prison, despite her being a trans woman, for the leak. In an unprecedented move, President Obama commuted the sentence in 2017.

The film begins on January 17 of that year as Manning’s lawyer Nancy Hollander receives the remarkable news from the president’s office. It follows Manning as she leaves prison after seven years inside to begin her new life as a woman, a very slow and difficult transition.

Film-maker Tim Travers Hawkins, given unprecedented access to Manning, produces a fascinating and intimate portrait. It is very hard to hear her recounting her treatment at the hands of the US military and government, described by a UN torture envoy in 2012 as “cruel, inhuman and degrading.”

The documentary really comes alive when you witness Manning’s joy and wonderment doing ordinary things like putting on lipstick or going to Times Square in New York and being reunited with one of her closest friends.

The film tries to give us an idea of what Manning has been through and that’s not easy to imagine. As Hollander says: “Chelsea will always be looking over her shoulder for the rest of her life. In this country once you have been marked as an enemy of the state I think you will always be an enemy of the state.”

In March this year she was placed behind bars once again for refusing to testify in an investigation into Wikileaks founder Julian Assange, following his arrest in Britain.

With the current intransigent US administration it could be a very long while before Manning, who can be held for 18 months, finds the peace and closure she so much desires.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
fotw
Film of the week / 5 June 2025
5 June 2025

MARIA DUARTE recommends an exposure of the state violence used against pro-Palestine protests in the US

round up
Cinema / 29 May 2025
29 May 2025

The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Along Came Love, The Ballad of Wallis Island, The Ritual, and Karate Kid: Legends

fotw
Film of the Week / 29 May 2025
29 May 2025

MARIA DUARTE recommends the powerful dramatisation of the true story of a husband and wife made homeless

IMPECCABLE: Benicio Del Toro as  Zsa-zsa Korda and Mia Threapleton as his daughter Liesl in The Phoenician Scheme
Film of the week / 22 May 2025
22 May 2025

MARIA DUARTE is in two minds about a peculiar latest offering from Wes Anderson

Similar stories
Features / 25 June 2024
25 June 2024
At long last the WikiLeaks founder is free. For all those who care about freedom of speech it’s time to celebrate, writes TIM DAWSON of the International Federation of Journalists