Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Understanding the dialectic that is at work
A valuable tool for comprehending which way the momentum is swinging the pendulum of British politics – and why, writes GAVIN O’TOOLE
NO USE FOR CONSENSUS: Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng

The Death of Consensus: 100 Years of British Political Nightmares
by Phil Tinline
Hurst, £20

CONCEALED within the pages of The Death of Consensus is a revelation that invites the reader to think about British political history not in terms of events, but processes.

While the author insists from the outset that “none of this is to suggest that history is somehow circular,” that is precisely what his analysis of the “nightmares” upon which a dominant consensus is constructed implies.

The historical logic Phil Tinline unpicks certainly feels Hegelian and, by making the continuities and ruptures explicit, each period he examines becomes a product of contradictions inherent or implicit in the preceding stage. He has discerned a dialectic.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
amazon
Books / 28 August 2025
28 August 2025

GAVIN O’TOOLE examines the fatal relationship between environmental crimes and politics in Brazil and the inspiration provided by Indigenous people

castro
Books / 8 August 2025
8 August 2025

GAVIN O’TOOLE welcomes the reissue of a seminal work of revolutionary theory that have genuine relevance in the current context

FORGOTTEN GENOCIDE: Regina Jose Galindo, “¿Quien puede bo
Book Review / 10 December 2024
10 December 2024
GAVIN O’TOOLE explores the resistance expressed by central American artists to their own erasure by US imperialist policies 
CHAVEZ FOREVER: A rally by Chavistas in Caracas supporting t
Book Review / 28 August 2024
28 August 2024
Here’s an antidote to the Venezuela election-induced tantrums of Western elites. GAVIN O’TOOLE reviews it
Similar stories
LABORATORY OF BULLYING: A scene from Ken Loach's Kes
Books / 27 March 2025
27 March 2025
JOHN GREEN recommends an entertaining, if harsh and instructive, study of bullying, discipline and power dynamics in schools and at work
(L) Friedrich August von Hayek, 1981; (R) John Maynard Keyne
Books / 27 February 2025
27 February 2025
ALEX HALL welcomes an accessible examination of the two strands of pro-capitalist thought which have defined the post-war economic policies of the West
Istanbul's Hagia Sofia Mosque
Book Review / 10 January 2025
10 January 2025
ANGUS REID wrestles with a detailed analysis of the competing religious alliances behind the ascendancy of conservative nationalism in today’s Turkey
FORGOTTEN GENOCIDE: Regina Jose Galindo, “¿Quien puede bo
Book Review / 10 December 2024
10 December 2024
GAVIN O’TOOLE explores the resistance expressed by central American artists to their own erasure by US imperialist policies