Skip to main content
Regional secretary with the National Education Union
Erdogan’s neo Sultanate
ANGUS REID wrestles with a detailed analysis of the competing religious alliances behind the ascendancy of conservative nationalism in today’s Turkey
Istanbul's Hagia Sofia Mosque [Hunanuk/CC]

The enduring hold of Islam in Turkey
David S Tonge, Hurst, £45

IF you can stand it, this book relays a sobering and detailed analysis of the competing religious alliances behind the ascendancy of conservative nationalism in today’s Turkey — a tale that is couched in such a wealth of obscure Islamic language and names as to be almost incomprehensible. 

But it packs a punch in its introduction and concluding chapters. Here President Erdogan seals the symbolic fusion of the hitherto secular state with Islam by reopening the vast Ayasofya mosque in Istanbul as a Muslim centre of worship. Religious use of the building had been prohibited since 1935, and the days of Ataturk’s determined secularisation of the Turkish state. 

This book details the provenance of religious groups from the end of the Ottoman empire onwards, the measures taken to suppress them in the 20th century, and their re-emergence as a political force in the 21st. It’s a complex story of religious factionalism on the political right. You need a working knowledge of Turkish history to keep up with David Tonge’s account of events from this little-known perspective, and to get some sense of what Turkish democracy has evolved into since the introduction of multiparty elections in 1950. The perspective of left political organising is absent from this account, and the whole book is the weaker for it.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Recep Tayyip Erdogan
2016 coup attempt / 23 May 2025
23 May 2025
FACING DOWN THE AKP: Disk and other trade unions attempt mar
Features / 8 December 2024
8 December 2024
The arrest of trade union leader Remzi Caliskan on charges of connections to the PKK, which have not been proven in nine years of investigation, is a worrying development for Turkey, writes KEMAL GOKTAS
Hezbollah members carry the coffins of two of their comrades
Book Review / 12 September 2024
12 September 2024
ALEX HALL recommends a meticulous and fascinating academic account of the development of Lebanon’s ‘Party of God’