Skip to main content
Should Auld Acquaintance Be Forgot: The Great Mistake of Scottish Independence by John Lloyd
Forceful but flawed case against home rule for Scotland
WISHFUL THINKING? Scottish independence rally, 2018

GIVEN the continued lack of political appetite for a well-informed, reasoned debate about Scottish independence, John Lloyd’s new book on the topic is welcome.

[[{"fid":"19522","view_mode":"inlineright","fields":{"format":"inlineright","field_file_image_alt_text[und][0][value]":false,"field_file_image_title_text[und][0][value]":false},"link_text":null,"type":"media","field_deltas":{"1":{"format":"inlineright","field_file_image_alt_text[und][0][value]":false,"field_file_image_title_text[und][0][value]":false}},"attributes":{"class":"media-element file-inlineright","data-delta":"1"}}]]By no means a dispassionate summary of the arguments — it comes out solidly against independence — it does at least give space to some of the salient points usually drowned out amid the soundbites and banalities.

Chief among these is the fact that the SNP appears set on exchanging one political, economic and monetary union within Britain for another governed from an even more remote centre, the European Union.

Lloyd carefully unpicks the flawed logic of that position while also calling into question the validity of the SNP’s claims that if Scotland does swap Britain for the EU, then it will somehow be allowed to sidestep the rigidly enforced rule that accessionary states must join the euro.

The main plank of his argument is that with oil revenues shrinking and without the annual £10 billion subsidy it receives from the British Treasury, an independent Scotland would face such a huge financial struggle that going it alone would just not be worth it.

Lloyd, a Scot who has been labour editor and a Moscow bureau chief at the Financial Times, initially makes his points in a lucid and highly engaging fashion. Whether one agrees with them or not, they are compellingly put.

But from chapter three onwards, the book begins to lose its fluency and, by the end, virtually all focus has gone.

There are too many pages on the failings of Scottish banks, a largely unnecessary excursion into the ins and outs of the country’s literature and a final chapter that fizzles out into a confused reflection on the situation in Quebec, which even by the author’s admission is not particularly analogous to that of Scotland.

What could have been a precise exposition of the arguments ranged against independence instead turns into a rather rambling look at Scotland in the round, interspersed in its later stages with too much consideration of how Scottish nationalists “hate and despise” the English, along with a rather ungallant section rubbishing the SNP’s Alex Salmond on the basis of his association with Russia Today.

At 214 pages plus, the book is hardly voluminous and it would have been much more effective at half that length, without the diversionary trips and with the arguments marshalled in a much clearer fashion.

Credit to Lloyd for writing the book but it’s a shame he couldn’t have done it more cogently.

Published by Polity, £20.

 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
(L) Mudlark kneels on a rocky shore, collecting objects; (R) Medieval pilgrim badge. Pics © London Museum
Exhibitions / 22 April 2025
22 April 2025

PETER MASON is enthralled by an assembly of objects, ancient and modern, that have lain in the mud of London’s river

POWER-DRESSING: Miriam Grace Edwards as Mary in Mrs Presiden
Theatre Review / 5 February 2025
5 February 2025
PETER MASON applauds a thought-provoking study of the relationship between a grieving woman and her photographer
CONSTRUCTIVISM FOR KIDS: Ballet Shoes at the National Theatr
Theatre Review / 9 December 2024
9 December 2024
PETER MASON is moved by a striking production of Noel Streatfeild’s enduringly popular children’s book
DOUBLE TAKE: Dominic Semwanga and Megan Keaveney as Fes and
Theatre review / 4 December 2024
4 December 2024
PETER MASON reckons the NYT’s production of Shakespeare’s comedy is the pick of the Christmas shows on offer in London 
Similar stories
Aboubakar Traore
Global Routes / 2 December 2024
2 December 2024
Two new releases from Burkina Faso and Niger, one from French-based Afro Latin The Bongo Hop, and rare Mexican bootlegs
ARROGANCE AND IGNORANCE: Group of six European men sitting,
Book Review / 24 September 2024
24 September 2024
FRANCOISE VERGES introduces a powerful new book that explores the damage done by colonial theft
(L) Chilean academic and photographer Luis Bustamante; (R) C
Exhibition Review / 11 July 2024
11 July 2024
Co-curator TOM WHITE introduces a father-and-son exhibition of photography documenting the experience and political engagement of Chilean exiles
Edgar Degas, Young Woman with Field Glasses, 1866-68, detail
Exhibition review / 7 June 2024
7 June 2024
HENRY BELL steps warily through the collection of a Glaswegian war profiteer to experience his collection of Degas’ remarkable images of working people