Skip to main content
Work with the NEU
Judges wrong for 30 years
Hundreds of convicted murderers could appeal after Supreme Court rules on joint enterprise

BRITISH judges have misinterpreted the law on controversial “joint enterprise” murder charges for decades, the Supreme Court ruled yesterday in a landmark judgement paving the way for hundreds of legal challenges.

A panel of Supreme Court justices, in a historic first sitting with the Privy Council’s judicial committee, concluded that the law on joint enterprise had been wrongly interpreted by criminal trial judges over the past 30 years.

Joint enterprise allows for individuals to be convicted of murder as a secondary party even if they weren’t the main perpetrator in committing the act.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
CONTROVERSY: A court artist sketch of Nicholas Johnson KC crossexamining nurse Lucy Letby at Manchester Crown Court, May 18 2023
Features / 14 September 2025
14 September 2025

Former judge ANSELM ELDERGILL examines the details and controversy of Lucy Letby’s trial and appeal in the context of famous historical wrongful convictions that prove both the justice system and legal activists make errors

Features / 8 March 2025
8 March 2025
In a legal system that is increasingly removing judicial discretion, the fundamental question remains whether justice requires a compassionate heart or a dispassionate application of Parliament’s will, writes ANSELM ELDERGILL