Skip to main content
Universal basic income – the fad is over
The lived experience of disabled people is the final nail in the coffin of the once-trendy concept of univeral basic income, writes ELLEN CLIFFORD

UNIVERSAL basic income (UBI) — a regular cash payment made to individuals without means-testing or conditionality — has been described as an idea whose time has come, supported across the political divide from free market libertarians to leftwingers attracted to the idea of emancipating the working class from wage labour.

Disabled people, as one of the groups at the sharp end of “welfare reform,” are not convinced that UBI can deliver the solution so desperately needed to fix the social security system.

A new report from Disabled People Against Cuts argues that the introduction of UBI could further disadvantage those who have suffered the most since 2010.

Although UBI pilots in India produced positive outcomes for disabled people, these tell us little more than that giving money to people with nothing is a good thing. Meanwhile, there is no precedent for replacing a complex, targeted social security system such as we have in Britain with a UBI.

Even the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development and World Bank, which are in favour of using UBI to ameliorate trends in the modern labour market such as rising job insecurity, reduced obligations on employers and lower wages, concede that it isn’t feasible to introduce it to Britain.

Existing benefit levels are so far below a guaranteed minimum income level here that it could only be financed through steep tax rises.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Reform UK Treasury spokesman Robert Jenrick speaking on social care during a press conference at Millbank Tower, London, July 30, 2026
Politics / 16 August 2026
16 August 2026

‘Ultimately, all of Reform's policies benefit big business and attack workers and the poor,’ Diane Abbott MP tells the Star

A pensioner holding bank notes
Opinion / 30 July 2026
30 July 2026

Critics of UBI underestimate both its political significance and its economic potential, writes BERT SCHOUWENBURG

Labour Party MP Stephen Timms
Features / 23 July 2026
23 July 2026

The government’s Pip review looks like a carefully managed exercise in legitimising future cuts to disability support, argues Dr DYLAN MURPHY

Pension / 11 July 2026
11 July 2026

MPs back measure for 66-year-olds but it won't end suffering, groups say