Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Canada’s environmental self-delusion
SYLVIA HIKINS recommends a graphic novel that lays bare the human and environmental costs of opencast mining in Alberta
Illustrations: Kate Beaton

Ducks — Two Years in the Oil Sands
by Kate Beaton
Jonathon Cape £25

 

KATE BEATON is a Canadian writer and cartoonist. The book, Ducks — Two Years in the Oil Sands, is her first full-length graphic narrative, a memoir dramatically played out in cartoon format.

Beaton comes from Cape Breton on Canada’s East Coast, an area where the major industries, oil and fishing, went into sharp decline and as a consequence, local people had to seek employment elsewhere.

At the same time, out west in Alberta, the massive oil sands were opening up for oil extraction. Beaton accepted a job there, unaware of exactly what she was getting into.

Most of the workers were male, living in camps, estranged from family and friends. Living alongside them, Beaton was forced to put up with a constant stream of sexism, misogyny and abuse, as well as their increased consumption of alcohol and drugs, a result of isolation and loneliness.

The once open prairie landscape was now stuffed with huge machinery, a constant reminder of what the oil industry does to nature and the shocking impact this is having on the indigenous Cree people.

The Crees were not consulted about the oil industry developments. But now the economic reality is that in order to survive, they also have to be part of it.

Canada has always been proud of its tradition of egalitarianism and respect for the wilderness, yet ironically, its support for the oil industry means air, water, land and lives are being ruined.

The book’s title, Ducks, alludes to 2008, when 200 migrating ducks descended in the oil sludge and died. This captured the public imagination and made headline news.

Kate Beaton’s natural cartooning powers create a multi-layered, dark and fascinating story told in both words and pictures. Remember Thatcher’s secretary of state for employment Norman Tebbit’s slogan, “Get on your bike,” peddled out  in 1981 at the Tory Party conference for those in the UK living in areas of high unemployment?

That’s what Kate Beaton did. She is still living with the consequences. It’s a story that has resonances for all of us.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
speedo
Theatre review / 6 June 2025
6 June 2025

SYLVIA HIKINS is bowled over by a wonderful show that both entertains and educates

Iman Aoun and Edward Muallem in Oranges and Stones
Best of 2024 / 3 December 2024
3 December 2024
A manifesto for change, feminism in the digital age and a wordless play by Palestinians
Girls Don't Play Guitars: Val, Sylvia, Pam and Mary.
Theatre review / 7 October 2024
7 October 2024
SYLVIA HIKINS relishes a brilliant untold Merseybeat story of how four talented women dared to break the mould
PRESSING AGENDAS: A Punch cartoon from 1867 mocks John Stuar
Books / 3 May 2024
3 May 2024
SYLVIA HIKINS is enthralled by a biography of an extraordinary, 19th-century mould-breaker who influenced policies regarding the status of women in society
Similar stories
A general view of Aberdeen Harbour in Scotland, which has be
Features / 28 February 2025
28 February 2025
Rich natural resources built Aberdeen twice, but today it lies almost abandoned, as our city faces a third major transition — and the renewable energy future threatens same old exploitation, warns LARA FLANNERY
(L) Three Studies of Isabel Rawsthorne 1967; (R) Self-Portra
Exhibition review / 16 January 2025
16 January 2025
RINA ARYA confronts the brutal operation of Francis Bacon’s approach to portraiture
STANDING STRONG: The RMT delegation at STUC women’s confer
Features / 26 October 2024
26 October 2024
ANN HENDERSON, of RMT Scotland, reports from STUC women’s conference in Glasgow earlier this week where sisters gathered to highlight the issues facing women in the workforce
Science and Society / 25 September 2024
25 September 2024
Sand and gravel underpin almost all urban development — but the extraction of these vital materials is unsustainable and causes untold damage, write ROX MIDDLETON, LIAM SHAW and MIRIAM GAUNTLETT