Skip to main content
Downing Street speech: Starmer offers no hope of real change
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during a meeting with the Crown Prince of Bahrain, Salman bin Hamad Al Khalifa at 10 Downing Street, London. Picture date: Tuesday August 27, 2024

AFTER seven weeks in office marked by a renewed austerity and scarred by far-right riots across the country, Sir Keir Starmer finally felt the need to speak to the country today.

He did so standing in the same Downing Street garden that David Cameron and Nick Clegg used to announce their coalition in 2010 and the brutal onset of austerity mark one.

Resolutely downbeat, the Prime Minister made no attempt to mimic Tony Blair’s “things can only get better” rhetoric from the last time a Labour government assumed office. Indeed, his warning was that “things will get worse before they get better.”

And they are already bad enough. Starmer is on firm ground in blaming the craven, corrupt and barely competent Conservatives for the state the country is in.

But he has to answer for the paucity of the solutions he offers and for his determination to govern within the basic parameters laid down by the Treasury, the City and Washington.

That determination not to think outside the Establishment box has already mandated keeping the two-child benefit cap, halting winter fuel payments to needy pensioners and pouring arms and resources into the unwinnable Ukraine conflict while continuing to ship munitions to support Israel’s genocide.

Starmer is clearly intent on staying the austerity course, as mandated by the bond markets. 

He warned again of a “tough” Budget coming up in October. Oddly he claimed that those with the broadest shoulders should bear the burden of righting the public finances, but that has not been his policy thus far — on the contrary, it has been the weakest, such as children living in poverty, who have been made to pay the price.

Unite leader Sharon Graham is right to say that his speech today was not the one the country needed.

“We should not pit pensioners against workers,” she said, adding that “we now need Labour to have the courage to make the right choices. To be Labour and fight for change for workers and our communities.”

Her proposed solution is correct too. It is indeed “time for a wealth tax on the super-rich and a tax on excess profits. We don't need more excuses about fiscal responsibility or talk of wealth creation,” she said.

Likewise, the Greens’ Carla Denyer is correct to argue that “Labour could choose to make things better for everyone if they were bolder and braver.

“What is being framed as tough choices is actually about political choices. People need a new approach, not misguided fiscal rules that are set to make things worse,” she said.

There is no sign that Starmer is listening to this sense. The trade union movement and the left therefore need to be urgently considering how to impose a change of course.

Unions will understandably be focused on ensuring that the promised new legislation on workers’ rights, including the repeal of the anti-union laws brought in by the last Tory government, is got over the line.

That is mired in a lack of clarity at present, with talk of many measures not seeing the light of day until next year, and business lobbying hard for indefinite “consultation” on those changes it finds particularly unappealing.

However, a wider agenda must also be kept in focus. Here again Graham’s remarks provide suggestions. 

Unions need to unite with pensioners’ organisations to campaign together against the cut in fuel payments this winter, and with the People’s Assembly to challenge the two-child cap, as well as backing the pro-Palestine and anti-fascist movements.

That is the only way to inject hope of real change into Starmer’s doom-laden Establishment agenda.

Morning Star call for advertising
More from this author
Clothing showing an image of Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer
Eyes Left / 2 April 2025
2 April 2025
ANDREW MURRAY wonders whether recent opinion polling and a fresh local authority by-election result in Ilford are an indication that the time is ripe for the left to make inroads
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during a joint press confere
Britain / 1 April 2025
1 April 2025
Protesters demonstrate as Chancellor Rachel Reeves is about
Britain / 26 March 2025
26 March 2025
Labour accused of ‘balancing the books off the backs of the poor’ in spring spending statement
Protesters on Whitehall in London, as Chancellor of the Exch
Britain / 26 March 2025
26 March 2025
Similar stories
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during a reception to celebr
Editorial: / 20 March 2025
20 March 2025
Unite union general secretary Sharon Graham, 21/12/2022
Labour Conference 2024 / 23 September 2024
23 September 2024
‘The fiscal rules are a noose around our neck,’ Unite's SHARON GRAHAM tells the Morning Star – it's time to tax the rich
An elderly woman holding pound coins in her hands
TUC 2024 / 8 September 2024
8 September 2024
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during his speech and press
Britain / 27 August 2024
27 August 2024
Left MPs and trade unionists accuse Sir Keir of choosing austerity, pain and poverty instead of taxing the super-rich