Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Reverend Stephens: God’s commandments v the Poor Law
MAT COWARD explores how the ‘Tory-Radical’ Christian minister became a fiery opponent of the Poor Law, advocating armed resistance against its brutal cruelty against the emerging working class
CHANGING FORTUNES: (L to R) An engraving of Joseph Rayner Stephens, by James Posselwhite after a painting by Benjamin Garside which was distributed with 25.000 copies of the chartist newspaper the Northern Star in November 1839. When Stephens less than a month later denounced the movement in reaction to the Newport Rising, chartists responded by publicly burning his portrait; the Reverend Joseph Rayner Stephens memorial plaque at the site of the former Stalybridge Town Hall, Greater Manchester

WHEN it came to opposing the Poor Law, said the reverend, it was every man’s Christian duty “to have his firelock, his cutlass, his sword, his pair of pistols or his pike, and for every woman to have her pair of scissors, and for every child to have its paper of pins and its box of needles, and let the men with torch in one hand and a dagger in the other put to death any and all who attempt to sever man and wife.”
 
Amen.
 
Clearly, he agreed with his contemporary, the Newcastle trade unionist Robert Lowery, that “All should have guns, for the man that could shoot a Pheasant would shoot a Tyrant.” (It’s often forgotten that the right to bear arms was a left-wing cause for centuries before it became identified with the US right).
 
Of course, we’re used to meeting “red vicars” in Rebel Britannia, but the odd thing about the Reverend Joseph Rayner Stephens is that he was no revolutionary.

For a short while, the Reverend Stephens was one of the best-known Chartist agitators in the country — but he always insisted that he was not a Chartist. He might sound red to our modern ears, but historians generally class him as a Tory-Radical, that curious 19th-century phenomenon that’s easier to recognise than to define.
 
Richard Oastler, who Stephens worked closely with, is the best remembered of the Tory-Radical faction, a man who believed that the old, tradition-based Toryism was being replaced by modern, ultra-capitalist Conservatism, under which the ruthless pursuit of profit and nothing else would create a spiritually dead country, disfigured by awful poverty and constant bloodshed between the classes.
 
Stephens, future firebrand and political prisoner, was born in Edinburgh in 1805, the son of a Methodist minister. He himself was ordained in the 1820s, starting his ministry in Stockholm and ending up in Ashton under Lyne.

But he was effectively expelled from the Wesleyan movement in the 1830s because he refused to stop campaigning for disestablishmentarianism — the idea that England should not have an official church (as it did then and does now, in the embarrassingly comical form of the Church of England).
 
He was also in trouble over less obscure matters. This was the time of the new Poor Law, an anti-welfare measure brought in by a free-market-obsessed government, which often resulted in families being confined in workhouses, split up into separate sexes and generations.

Oastler called them “prisons for the poor,” and Stephens agreed. So did many of the local working-class Methodists, and seeing the expelled preacher working for factory reform as well, some seceded from official Methodism to establish “Stephensite” chapels. Although largely confined to one region, “Stephensism” was, for a time, quite a big deal, controlling at least 10 places of worship.
 
Arguing that by working against the cruelty of the factory system and the Poor Law, he was attempting to “apply God’s commandments” to life in a supposedly Christian society, Stephens became a famous and effective orator, addressing crowds, it is said, of up to 100,000 across northern England.

His link-up with the Chartists, whose aims were a democratic Parliament, was probably tactical rather than ideological; they had the organisation and the membership, which allowed him to speak to and write for a huge national audience.
 
His public speeches were characteristically untroubled by any thoughts of moderation, as he encouraged workers to break up meetings of the Poor Law administrators and to have revenge on local businesses which co-operated with the Poor Law, and advised his listeners that the government would take them a lot more seriously once they were all carrying weapons.

He was never going to get away with this for long, and at Christmas 1838, he was arrested for a “seditious speech” given at an illegal rally in Hyde on November 14.
 
Whether from lack of money or lack of modesty, or both, he chose to defend himself. The jury rapidly found him guilty — which he pretty obviously was — and he was sentenced to 18 months in prison, followed by five years of what we would today call probation.
 
Albeit more quietly and carefully than before his imprisonment and with fewer references to righteous bullets, the Reverend Stephens continued to campaign for workplace reforms, against child labour, in favour of trade unions and on behalf of the unemployed, until his death in 1879.

You can sign up for Mat Coward’s Rebel Britannia Substack at www.rebelbrit.substack.com for more strange strikes, peculiar protests, bizarre boycotts, unusual uprisings and different demos.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Organic beetroot / Pic: Evan-Amos/CC
Gardening / 7 June 2025
7 June 2025

Beet likes warmth, who doesn’t, so attention to detail is required if you’re to succeed, writes MAT COWARD

AIR WAR: A spitfire squadron flies to battle the Nazis, 1945
Features / 23 May 2025
23 May 2025

MAT COWARD tells the extraordinary story of the second world war Spitfire pilot who became Britain’s most famous Stalag escaper, was awarded an MBE, mentored a generation of radio writers and co-founded a hardline Marxist-Leninist party

SCIFI
Books / 22 May 2025
22 May 2025

Generous helpings of Hawaiian pidgin, rather good jokes, and dodging the impostors

Reverend Edward George Maxted
History / 16 May 2025
16 May 2025

MAT COWARD tells the story of Edward Maxted, whose preaching of socialism led to a ‘peasants’ revolt’ in the weeks running up to the first world war

Similar stories
TALK OF THE TOWN: (L to R) John Wilkes caricatured by Willia
Features / 25 January 2025
25 January 2025
Despite his wealthy background and membership of a secretive aristocratic occult club, the radical politician forged an alliance with the working class to fight for democracy and free speech against the Georgian elite, writes MAT COWARD
Labour MP Philip Noel-Baker had a Nobel Prize and an Olympic
Features / 30 December 2024
30 December 2024
MAT COWARD offers a roll call of refuseniks – some for political reasons, others for quirky reasons of their own
Major John Cartwright
Features / 2 October 2024
2 October 2024
MAT COWARD traces how ill health and voracious reading transformed a military man into the Father of Reform, championing American independence, universal suffrage and secret ballots against Establishment resistance
MILITARIST ANTHEM: 
I Vow to Thee, My Country is performed a
Features / 28 September 2024
28 September 2024
MAT COWARD unearths Gustav Holst’s radical roots, from meetings at William Morris’s house to pamphlet-printing and agitation with the Red Vicar of Thaxted — and laments that he is remembered today for the entirely wrong reason