Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Reverend Stephens: God’s commandments v the Poor Law
MAT COWARD explores how the ‘Tory-Radical’ Christian minister became a fiery opponent of the Poor Law, advocating armed resistance against its brutal cruelty against the emerging working class
CHANGING FORTUNES: (L to R) An engraving of Joseph Rayner Stephens, by James Posselwhite after a painting by Benjamin Garside which was distributed with 25.000 copies of the chartist newspaper the Northern Star in November 1839. When Stephens less than a month later denounced the movement in reaction to the Newport Rising, chartists responded by publicly burning his portrait; the Reverend Joseph Rayner Stephens memorial plaque at the site of the former Stalybridge Town Hall, Greater Manchester [(L to R) Public domain - Nick Harrison/flickr/CC]

WHEN it came to opposing the Poor Law, said the reverend, it was every man’s Christian duty “to have his firelock, his cutlass, his sword, his pair of pistols or his pike, and for every woman to have her pair of scissors, and for every child to have its paper of pins and its box of needles, and let the men with torch in one hand and a dagger in the other put to death any and all who attempt to sever man and wife.”
 
Amen.
 
Clearly, he agreed with his contemporary, the Newcastle trade unionist Robert Lowery, that “All should have guns, for the man that could shoot a Pheasant would shoot a Tyrant.” (It’s often forgotten that the right to bear arms was a left-wing cause for centuries before it became identified with the US right).
 
Of course, we’re used to meeting “red vicars” in Rebel Britannia, but the odd thing about the Reverend Joseph Rayner Stephens is that he was no revolutionary.

For a short while, the Reverend Stephens was one of the best-known Chartist agitators in the country — but he always insisted that he was not a Chartist. He might sound red to our modern ears, but historians generally class him as a Tory-Radical, that curious 19th-century phenomenon that’s easier to recognise than to define.
 
Richard Oastler, who Stephens worked closely with, is the best remembered of the Tory-Radical faction, a man who believed that the old, tradition-based Toryism was being replaced by modern, ultra-capitalist Conservatism, under which the ruthless pursuit of profit and nothing else would create a spiritually dead country, disfigured by awful poverty and constant bloodshed between the classes.
 
Stephens, future firebrand and political prisoner, was born in Edinburgh in 1805, the son of a Methodist minister. He himself was ordained in the 1820s, starting his ministry in Stockholm and ending up in Ashton under Lyne.

But he was effectively expelled from the Wesleyan movement in the 1830s because he refused to stop campaigning for disestablishmentarianism — the idea that England should not have an official church (as it did then and does now, in the embarrassingly comical form of the Church of England).
 
He was also in trouble over less obscure matters. This was the time of the new Poor Law, an anti-welfare measure brought in by a free-market-obsessed government, which often resulted in families being confined in workhouses, split up into separate sexes and generations.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
HISTORY MADE: A plaque at the Old Bailey dedicated to the case of William Penn and William Mead — and the jury who acted on their conscience
Features / 2 September 2025
2 September 2025

The heroism of the jury who defied prison and starvation conditions secured the absolute right of juries to deliver verdicts based on conscience — a convention which is now under attack, writes MAT COWARD

CAUSE AND EFFECT: Maturing apples and and apple pie / pics: (L to R) George Chernilevsky and Roozitaa both CC
Gardening / 16 August 2025
16 August 2025

As apple trees blossom to excess it remains to be seen if an abundance of fruit will follow. MAT COWARD has a few tips to see you through a nervy time
 

‘SEDITION AND BLASPHEMY’: (L to R) Blackfriars Rotunda, 1820 - view from the top of the Albion Mills; a political rowdiness / Pic (L to R): Frederick Birnie; Old and New London both Public domain
Politics / 15 August 2025
15 August 2025

While an as-yet-unnamed new left party struggles to be born, MAT COWARD looks at some of the wild and wonderful names of workers’ organisations past that have been lost to time

crime
Crime Fiction / 12 August 2025
12 August 2025

Timeloop murder, trad family MomBomb, Sicilian crime pages and Craven praise

Similar stories
Reverend Edward George Maxted
History / 16 May 2025
16 May 2025

MAT COWARD tells the story of Edward Maxted, whose preaching of socialism led to a ‘peasants’ revolt’ in the weeks running up to the first world war

TALK OF THE TOWN: (L to R) John Wilkes caricatured by Willia
Features / 25 January 2025
25 January 2025
Despite his wealthy background and membership of a secretive aristocratic occult club, the radical politician forged an alliance with the working class to fight for democracy and free speech against the Georgian elite, writes MAT COWARD
Actors rehearsing for a performance of Another Christmas Car
Features / 28 December 2024
28 December 2024
Charles Dickens was facing a return to the destitution that had blighted his childhood, and it was this which drove him to write the remarkable best-seller which changed the politics of Christmas forever, writes MAT COWARD
MILITARIST ANTHEM: 
I Vow to Thee, My Country is performed a
Features / 28 September 2024
28 September 2024
MAT COWARD unearths Gustav Holst’s radical roots, from meetings at William Morris’s house to pamphlet-printing and agitation with the Red Vicar of Thaxted — and laments that he is remembered today for the entirely wrong reason