Nothing, says ANDY HEDGECOCK, can rescue this undistinguished amalgam of ponderous melodrama and shallow philosophical speculation
SULEIMAN MOURAD’S book, in the shape of a lengthy discourse with leftist academic Perry Anderson, is a seminal guide to Islam.
He appreciates that the religion is best analysed by recognising that the centrality of ideas and values in determining the origins, role and contribution of a belief system has to coexist with an understanding of its interaction with more materialistic phenomenon such as political economy, class struggle and anti-imperialism.
Basic Marxism, one might say, but nonetheless in need of reiteration when more idealist interpretations start to claim the ascendancy — something which is certainly the case at the present time.
MARTIN HALL welcomes a plea for greater compassion between believer and non-believer via the framework of philosophical enquiry
ALEX HALL welcomes a history of the Bund, and its emphatic demand for working-class solidarity across racial and ethnic difference
BRENT CUTLER searches a new history of contemporary Iran for an understanding of the Islamic Republic, finding both interesting detail and glaring omissions
The selection, analysis and interpretation of historical ‘facts’ always takes place within a paradigm, a model of how the world works. That’s why history is always a battleground, declares the Marx Memorial Library



