Skip to main content
Time is right to reform Lord Advocate role, says Law Society
Concerns have grown after Dorothy Bain KC (right) recently stepped down as Lord Advocate when it emerged she briefed First Minister John Swinney (left) on charges facing former SNP chief executive Peter Murrell almost a year before these were made public

THE “time is right” to consult on whether Scotland’s most senior prosecutor should retain a cabinet role as legal adviser, according to the Law Society of Scotland.

Concerns have grown after Dorothy Bain KC recently stepped down as Lord Advocate when it emerged she briefed First Minister John Swinney on charges facing former SNP chief executive Peter Murrell almost a year before these were made public.

Pointing to the SNP’s 2021 manifesto pledge to consult on separating the roles, Law Society of Scotland president Serena Sutherland said: “The time is right to honour that commitment.

“Should the same person serve as both a Scottish government minister and its most senior legal adviser, while also heading the system of prosecution?

“That is an important constitutional question which deserves careful public consideration.”

The Scottish government said: “A report on the law officers’ roles and functions, published earlier this year, sets out how and why the current system works and its strengths. 

“Careful consideration would be required if there were to be any changes to the ways in which the law officers’ various functions were allocated.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Nicola Sturgeon with Peter Murrell as they cast their votes in the 2019 General Election at Broomhouse Park Community Hall in Glasgow
Opinion / 1 June 2026
1 June 2026

KENNY MacASKILL looks at the depth of the corruption tolerated within the Scottish National Party and the efforts to keep it from public scrutiny

First Minister and SNP leader John Swinney speaking during a press conference at Grassmarket Apex Hotel, Edinburgh, following the 2026 Holyrood elections, May 9, 2026
Features / 11 May 2026
11 May 2026

The new Scottish Parliament looks set to continue a cycle of managerial tinkering while public services face the axe, writes STEPHEN LOW

People take part in a protest in Parliament Square, London, July 12, 2025
Britain / 1 September 2025
1 September 2025