Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
The case for the railways
WILL PODMORE welcomes a demonstration of the incomparable virtues of rail travel, and the political obstacles to realising its potential 
RATIONAL FUTURE: Passenger and freight train on the West Coast Main Line in Warwickshire, England

How the railways will fix the future: rediscovering the essential brilliance of the iron road
Gareth Dennis, Repeater, £10.99


    
IN this splendid book, railway engineer Gareth Dennis urges the vital importance of railways. As he argues, public transport does not need inventing. We’ve solved the technology challenges for urban and long-distance transport, just as we have solved the problems of getting clean water and generating electricity.

We have all the skills and tools we need to solve our problems. All we lack is the political will, not the technological capability. He asks, should the railways be nationalised? And answers, yes, absolutely, but adds that this is only the first small step on a much larger journey. 

The idea that there can be meaningful competition in a complex network like the railways is bizarre. Railways should not be competing with each other. Their real competition is with road and air.

Conventional electrification is the only long-term solution. Hydrogen and battery trains are not efficient or cost-effective over their lifetime. Electrification, resignalling, track renewals, earthworks and drainage, platform and accessibility corrections, all need rolling programmes of work steered by a strategic plan. Rolling programmes are far better for staff than episodic projects: boom and bust largely end; strong teams build up over years; and retaining skills is far easier.

The British railway has shown that a franchised railway system of private operators will ultimately self-destruct. Consortia of banks initially ran the rolling stock leasing companies and sent their profits to tax havens, paying billions to shareholders, while refusing to invest in upgraded track layouts, electrification or modern control systems.

We have also suffered the near death of our train manufacturing industry, as there was no incentive to continue British Rail’s programme of fleet renewals. There is a worldwide lack of capacity to build new rolling stock. Clearly the “free market” cannot meet our needs, so the state needs to fill the gap.

Dennis argues that: “Railways... are the safest and most energy-efficient means of transport we’ve conceived of and likely ever will conceive of.” Across the EU in 2015-19 the risk of death for rail passengers was about 28 times less than for car occupants. These are safety statistics from the International Railway Safety Council.

As he explains, steel wheels on steel rails give significant energy efficiency benefits. In the UK, road transport alone accounts for a quarter of our total emissions, rail for 0.4 per cent. The greenhouse gas emissions of a train journey per passenger mile are a quarter of those of a car journey and a fifth of those of a plane trip.

Railways move more people and more goods with less infrastructure and less land take. One locomotive can haul the equivalent of up to 80 HGVs. A two-track railway can carry ten or 20 times more people per hour than a six-lane motorway. 

Investing in schools results in a benefit, and the investment pays for itself. When our NHS keeps people healthy so they can keep active and working, the return on our investment comes from fewer people having to fall back on social security. When our railway keeps passengers and goods moving more efficiently and keeps the economy more buoyant, it’s worth it.

Yet the Treasury is innately hostile to policies which involve upfront investment for a long-term return. As one ex-mandarin put it: “I was trained to be sceptical of spend-now-save-later proposals.” We need to wrest power away from the Treasury before we abolish it.

History has shown, again and again, that only the collective action of well-organised workers can ensure that decent conditions, pay and safety are maintained. Strong unions achieve better feelings of collective and personal responsibility for safety, as Dennis has observed over the years.

A 2013 study of 31 countries titled Worker Health Is Good For The Economy https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23849285/  found that union density was the most important influence on improving workplace safety, health and GDP. 

This book has a wonderfully positive message for our railways, and a message that applies more widely than the railway: plan for the future, and build the collective power of the working class.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
A MAN FOR ALL SEASONS: (L to R) Church of St Mary Magdalene
Books / 13 March 2025
13 March 2025
WILL PODMORE recommends an excellent and useful introduction to a lesser-known giant of the scientific revolution in Britain
EVOLUTION OF GOTHIC FROM ISLAMIC: Arches of the former mosqu
Books / 5 February 2025
5 February 2025
WILL PODMORE is enthralled by the convincing case that guilds of Islamic craftsmen were responsible for the European gothic style
GROOMED TO RULE: Eton College pupils taking part in the ‘P
Books / 5 January 2025
5 January 2025
WILL PODMORE is intrigued by a study the British ruling class that follows statistical analysis with totally inadequate proposals for change
MOST DIVISIVE OF ISSUES: Migrants are brought in to Dover, K
Books / 27 November 2024
27 November 2024
WILL PODMORE welcomes a well-written and pacey account of the run-up to the 2024 general election
Similar stories
Aslef general secretary Mick Whelan (centre) on the picket l
Features / 22 February 2025
22 February 2025
Aslef general secretary MICK WHELAN speaks to Ben Chacko about rail renationalisation, the Employment Rights Bill and why we shouldn’t write off this Labour government
Shadow Energy Secretary Ed Miliband on board the jack-up bar
Features / 10 October 2024
10 October 2024
The government’s reliance on unproven and short-termist technology won’t deliver answers to today’s energy crisis, warns MARK MASLIN
TUC 2024 / 9 September 2024
9 September 2024
From a progressive transport agenda, to public spending, investment and sectoral collective bargaining, our union wants to see the long-overdue improvements that workers need and deserve, says MICK LYNCH