Skip to main content
The case against ‘Western’ Marxism
RICHARD CLARKE applauds the assertion that Western Marxism represents a withdrawal from action to change the world into the academy
THE DISRUPTORS: Frankfurt School regulars in Heidelberg, April 1964: Horkheimer is front left, Adorno front right, and Habermas is in the background, right, running his hand through his hair. Siegfried Landshut is in the background left. [Jeremy J Shapiro/CC]

Western Marxism: How It Was Born, How It Died, How It Can Be Reborn
Domenico Losurdo, Monthly Review Press, £20

THIS is an important book on an important subject. For some who, like this reviewer, failed to see the relevance of much academic Marxist discourse in the 1970s and ‘80s to their own political activity it will offer some reassurance: there wasn’t much.  

First published in 2017, this first English translation of Italian communist philosopher, historian and politician Domenico Losurdo’s text is a trenchant criticism of a school of intellectual discourse from the “Frankfurt School” of the 1930s onwards.  

Losurdo begins by documenting the separation of “Western” from “Eastern” (sometimes “classical” or ‘orthodox”) Marxism especially in relation to the latter’s development after the 1917 October Revolution. Following the failure of revolution to spread throughout Europe some left intellectuals were unable to come to terms with the contradictory realities of building a state capable of resisting its encirclement by imperialism. 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
BROAD PLURALIST APPROACH: Adopted by nearly all the left parties in Europe including France Insoumise / Pic: France Insoumise/flickr/CC
Features / 25 April 2026
25 April 2026

JOHN REES replies to Claudia Webbe

LIBERATION: Mission Robinson literacy class in the La Vega neighbourhood of Caracas. Applying the Cuban literacy method ‘Yes, I can!’ - the state provides free textbooks and educational videos / Piv: Oriana Elicabe/orianomada/flickr/CC
Features / 13 February 2026
13 February 2026

ISAAC SANEY points to the global stakes involved in defending the Cuban revolution against imperialism and calls for resistance

Statue of Oliver Cromwell
Full Marx / 2 February 2026
2 February 2026

The selection, analysis and interpretation of historical ‘facts’ always takes place within a paradigm, a model of how the world works. That’s why history is always a battleground, declares the Marx Memorial Library

heavens
Book Review / 3 December 2025
3 December 2025

BEN CHACKO welcomes a masterful analysis that puts class struggle back at the heart of our understanding of China’s revolution