Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Intriguing confrontation let down by script limitations
BEST EFFORT: Simon Bird as Freud and Séan Browne as Lewis

Freud’s Last Session
King’s Head Theatre

 

CS LEWIS’S 1933 novel The Pilgrim’s Regress featured a character called Sigismund Enlightenment who is referred to as a “vain and ignorant old man.” It was a barely veiled swipe at the psychoanalyst Sigismund Freud whose almost total disregard for religion rubbed the recently converted author up the wrong way.

Perhaps fortunately the two never met, but their ideas have been brought together frequently, most notably in Armand Nicholi’s book A Question of God which provided the inspiration for Mark St Germain’s 2011 play.  

It is September 1 1939 and Lewis (Sean Browne) has made the train journey from Oxford, against the traffic of those leaving London with war looming, to visit the ageing Freud (Simon Bird) in his Hampstead living room. The conversation quickly turns to God. Freud cannot fathom why someone as educated as Lewis “can abandon truth and embrace an insidious lie” in the form of Christianity.  

Lewis, the self-proclaimed “most reluctant convert in all of England” is anything but. Obsessed with binary moral codes he has a deeply held belief that human conscience is created by God, which unsurprisingly sends the stubborn and impatient Freud into fits of frustration.  

The animated discussion has the feel of a sparring match until it’s dramatically interrupted by an air raid siren, unearthing Lewis’s trauma from the trenches of WWI. Frozen and frightened his belief in God seemingly provides him with little comfort and Freud seizes on this fact once the alarm has passed. But soon Freud’s own pain takes hold of him and the two find some common ground on which to bond.
 
St Germain provides us with an intriguing snapshot but eventually the ongoing back-and-forths begin to feel a little staid and fail to truly get under the skin of the characters. Bird and Browne do all they can to bring truth to these historical figures but there’s not enough for director Peter Darney to draw out from an ultimately predictable script.

Runs until February 12. Box Office: kingsheadtheatre.com

Mayer Wakefield

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
cockfosters
Theatre review / 6 May 2025
6 May 2025

MAYER WAKEFIELD laments the lack of audience interaction and social diversity in a musical drama set on London’s Underground

(L to R) Arian Nik as Samir, Shazia Nicholls as Faiza) Sabrina Sandhu as Harleen
Culture / 15 April 2025
15 April 2025
MAYER WAKEFIELD has reservations about the direction of a play centered on a DVLA re-training session for three British-Pakistani motorists
AWKWARD HOMOGENISING OF RCIAL GROUPS: Gershwyn Eustache Jnr
Theatre Review / 3 March 2025
3 March 2025
MAYER WAKEFIELD wonders why this 1978 drama merits a revival despite demonstrating that the underlying theme of racism in the UK remains relevant
(L) Playwright Richard Bean; (R) John Hollingworth as Donald
Interview / 5 November 2024
5 November 2024
MAYER WAKEFIELD speaks to playwright Richard Bean about his new play Reykjavik that depicts the exploitation of the Hull-based “far-fleet” trawlermen
Similar stories
nazi nightmares
Books / 2 May 2025
2 May 2025

GORDON PARSONS is fascinated by a unique dream journal collected by a Jewish journalist in Nazi Berlin

(L to R) the book cover; Labour Party election poster 1945;
Books / 3 December 2024
3 December 2024
MICHAL BONCZA recommends a compact volume that charts the art of propagating ideas across the 20th century
Culture / 2 September 2024
2 September 2024
James Brandon Lewis Quartet, Art Tatum Trio and Kevin Figes
Anthony Hopkins as Sigmund Freud
Film of the Week: / 13 June 2024
13 June 2024
MARIA DUARTE recommends a drama that brings together a superstar Atheist and a born-again Christian in a psychoanalytic consulting room