Skip to main content
The problem with CS Lewis

After a ruinous run at Tolkien, the streaming platforms are moving on to Narnia — a naff mix of religious allegory, colonial attitudes, and thinly veiled prejudices that is beyond rescuing, writes STEPHEN ARNELL

CS Lewis in 1947 [Pic: Scan of photograph by Arthur Strong]

“If Lucy had really met a faun, that is, a satyr, the result would have been a rape, not a tea party” — Christopher Tolkien on his father’s view of Narnia.

WITH “Barbie/Mumblecore” director/actor Greta Gerwig prepping Netflix’s no doubt eye-wateringly high-budgeted adaptation of CS Lewis’s Narnia novels, now is surely an appropriate time to discuss “the problem with CS Lewis.”

Pop singer Charli XCX is reportedly in line to play White Witch Jadis in Gerwig’s take on the Narnia-verse, which appears to be the first front in the war against the traditional version of CS Lewis’s Christian-proselytising, misogynistic and generally toffee-nosed fantasy legendarium.

Not to knock Ms XCX, but the character of Jadis has been played by thespians in the league of Tilda Swinton, Sheila Hancock, and Barbara Kellerman, so it might prove a stretch for the 32-year-old novice actor to convince as the evil witch, although I could of course be mistaken.

Lewis v Tolkien: punch-up in the quad

‘Not at all likeable either as a person or a thinker’

‘We face it with our hearts even bigger than our feet’

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Elon Musk listens as President Donald Trump meets with India
Features / 18 February 2025
18 February 2025
STEPHEN ARNELL sees parallels between the US tech billionaire and HG Wells’s literary creation
David Lynch pictured in 2007
Features / 7 February 2025
7 February 2025
David Lynch’s classic 1980 film The Elephant Man has some cruel parallels with Britain in 2025, argues STEPHEN ARNELL
 Photograph of Theodore Roosevelt, 1904
Features / 8 January 2025
8 January 2025
Between Musk’s bizarre British power grab and Trump’s overtly corporate agenda, modern robber barons face a growing backlash — and history shows how determined leaders can tame ultra-rich excess, writes STEPHEN ARNELL
Thomas Cromwell in 1532 painted by Hans Holbein the Younger
Features / 21 December 2024
21 December 2024
There is no denying Thomas Cromwell's positive and progressive impact on English politics, argues STEPHEN ARNELL
Similar stories
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe at Leeds Playhouse
Theatre review / 27 November 2024
27 November 2024
SUSAN DARLINGTON is unmoved by a production full of spectacular tableax but without emotional connection to the characters
PERMA-TOURING TROUBADOUR: Jeffrey Lewis plays The Crescent,
Gig review / 4 September 2024
4 September 2024
JAMES WALSH happily capitulates to a master of DIY depression and despair
Culture / 2 September 2024
2 September 2024
James Brandon Lewis Quartet, Art Tatum Trio and Kevin Figes
Anthony Hopkins as Sigmund Freud
Film of the Week: / 13 June 2024
13 June 2024
MARIA DUARTE recommends a drama that brings together a superstar Atheist and a born-again Christian in a psychoanalytic consulting room