Skip to main content
Job vacancy with the National Education Union
The dangers of medicalising gender
SONYA ANDERMAHR admires a candid history of the NHS service and its mistreatment of young people with gender dysphoria
[Ted Eyton/CC]

Time to Think
Hannah Barnes, Swift Press, £20

“ARE we hurting children?” is the question that lies at the heart of this timely and meticulously researched investigation into the medical scandal at the Tavistock and Portman Trust’s Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS).

The service opened in 1989 to provide talking therapies to young people struggling with their gender identity. Treatment initially consisted of careful and lengthy exploration of the issues and family counselling in a supportive setting. It involved small numbers of patients, mainly boys, who exhibited gender incongruence before puberty. Most of these boys desisted and grew up to be gay. 

By the time of the announcement of the clinic’s closure last year, the number of young people being treated had skyrocketed into the thousands; the vast majority, representing a rise of over 4,000 per cent, were now teenage girls exhibiting extreme distress and complex problems. 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Trans Pride protest march in Brighton in July 2023
Book Review / 29 February 2024
29 February 2024
SONYA ANDERMAHR finds a voice worth listening to in the candid account of a trans woman who came to question gender identity politics
URGENCY: People in Parliament Square, London, take part in t
Features / 5 September 2022
5 September 2022
The Star publishes an adapted political statement for the CPB women’s commission by SONYA ANDERMAHR, who argues that the stakes have seldom been higher for women, amid the fightback against the cost-of-living crisis and the defence of their sex-based rights
A show of hands by 187 female sewing machinists at the Ford
INTERNATIONAL WOMEN'S DAY / 8 March 2022
8 March 2022
SONYA ANDERMAHR looks at women’s role in the labour movement past and present
The proclamation of International Women’s Day in Petrograd
Features / 8 March 2021
8 March 2021
A far cry from today’s ‘diversity’ and ‘inclusion’ agenda, International Women’s Day has its origins in the revolutionary labour politics of the early 20th century, SONYA ANDERMAHR reminds us
Similar stories
RADICAL: Greta Thunberg urges MEPs to show climate leadershi
Books / 3 April 2025
3 April 2025
JOHN GREEN explores the argument that psychiatry needs to move away from the idea of just seeing and treating the individual
Britain / 11 December 2024
11 December 2024
VICTIM BLAMING: Kemi Badenoch has never met a disadvantaged
Features / 31 October 2024
31 October 2024
The dangerous rhetoric around neurodiversity from the Conservative leadership candidate threatens hard-won protections and social progress, writes CAILEAN McBRIDE
Kaukab Stewart MSP arrives for an SNP group meeting at the S
Features / 5 October 2024
5 October 2024
An independent review has condemned the rape crisis centre for failing to protect women or put survivors first. SUSAN GALLOWAY asks how it came to this