Skip to main content
An end to the academy school gravy train?
As the government moves to rein in academy freedoms, former darling of conservative education reform Katharine Birbalsingh cries ‘Marxism.’ Education columnist ROBERT POOLE examines how academisation has failed our children while enriching executives and empowering ideologues at the expense of democratic accountability
CONSERVATIVE POSTER CHILD: School head Katharine Birbalsingh

THERE is perhaps no more controversial figure in education than Katharine Birbalsingh, the head teacher of Michaela Free School in Wembley Park. Birbalsingh was the darling of the Gove-led Conservative education team and once boasted of having a framed letter from him on her office wall. So revered by Conservatives was she that she was invited to speak at Conservative Party conferences and was even appointed chair of the Social Mobility Commission.

Birbalsingh was the poster child for conservative education reform. Although she describes herself as a “small-C conservative,” her pedagogy is deeply connected with the Conservative Party. Her school, while an excellent exam factory that produces impressive results, is run like a military boot camp. Children sit in silence, walk down corridors in silence and sing God Save the King. 

The question here is, first, do the ends justify the means? Second, who decides that the end result is what we really want anyway? Pupils excel in public exams based around a narrow curriculum focused on recalling knowledge, but is this the only metric that matters?

The winds of change

The academy experiment

The true purpose of academisation

Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
TEACHERS STAND TALL: Members of the NEU make a clear show of
Features / 14 April 2025
14 April 2025
The NEU’s annual conference promises heated debate, with motions on international politics, curriculum reform and union amalgamation likely to provoke strong reactions and challenge the status quo, writes Education for Tomorrow editor ROBERT POOLE
ELITE ENDORSEMENT: Keir Starmer hosts Adolescence writer Jac
Features / 9 April 2025
9 April 2025
The series unveils uncomfortable truths about youth alienation and online radicalisation — but the real crisis lies in austerity and the absence of class consciousness in addressing young people’s disillusionment, says teacher ROBERT POOLE
CRUCIAL HISTORY: A silent crowd follows the funeral processi
Features / 17 March 2025
17 March 2025
From colonialism to the Troubles, the story of England’s first colony is one of exploitation, resistance, and solidarity — and one we should fight to ensure is told, writes teacher ROBERT POOLE
NEU delgation to Cuba
Features / 6 November 2024
6 November 2024
ROBERT POOLE reports back from his mission to Cuba delivering aid and learning from Cuban educators
Similar stories
NEU delegate David Room speaks at the union’s conference i
NEU Conference 2025 / 15 April 2025
15 April 2025
NEU conference urges Labour to fix school funding crisis by getting rid of academy bosses earning over £500,000
TIME TO ACT ON PROMISE: Education secretary, Bridget Phillip
Features / 13 December 2024
13 December 2024
The teaching watchdog was declared 'not fit for purpose' in 2007. The time has come to abolish it once and for all, writes BERNIE EVANS