Skip to main content
MSPs call for explanation of Goodwillie rape case halt
David Goodwillie's accuser 'couldn't consent to anything'

Key witnesses said yesterday that footballer David Goodwillie's accuser "couldn't consent to anything" on the night they had sex as MSPs demanded to know why prosecutors dropped rape charges.

The star footballer faced new testimony from a Bathgate pub's stewards yesterday that Livingston woman Denise Clair appeared "hit by a sledgehammer" and barely capable of speech as a "stone-cold sober" Mr Goodwillie bundled her into a taxi on the night of January 1 2011.

Ms Clair, who has waived her right to anonymity, is suing the footballer for £500,000 in damages after Scottish crown prosecutors told her they did not wish to proceed against Mr Goodwillie.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
E Jean Carroll [Pic: Courtesy of Dogwoof]
Film of the Week / 23 July 2026
23 July 2026

MARIA DUARTE recommends the true story of the remarkable woman who sued Donald Trump for sexual assault not once, but twice

Peter Murrell being jailed at the High Court in Edinburgh
Opinion / 7 July 2026
7 July 2026

KENNY MacASKILL says the lines between party, government and Civil Service in Scotland have been blurred and we need a thorough investigation into how

CONTROVERSY: A court artist sketch of Nicholas Johnson KC crossexamining nurse Lucy Letby at Manchester Crown Court, May 18 2023
Features / 14 September 2025
14 September 2025

Former judge ANSELM ELDERGILL examines the details and controversy of Lucy Letby’s trial and appeal in the context of famous historical wrongful convictions that prove both the justice system and legal activists make errors