Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Scottish Labour after the Brighton conference
The contrast between Scottish Labour’s radical proposals and the SNP’s ‘business as usual’ agenda could scarcely be greater, writes STEPHEN LOW
Scottish Labour leader Richard Leonard

“THE shareholder dividend and the profit motive should never have had any place in our National Health Service. And it should have no place in the delivery of our bus services, in the delivery of our post, no place in our prisons and no place in our asylum system.”

That was Scottish Labour leader Richard Leonard’s declaration to Labour’s Brighton conference last month. This statement, as much as any of the policy announcements, shows how different Scottish Labour is from other parties in Holyrood. 

Indeed, under Leonard’s leadership, Scottish Labour is not just offering something different in Scottish politics, but something new. A radicalism that has been all but absent in the era of devolution.  

This year has marked the 20thanniversary of the setting up of the Scottish Parliament, prompting many laudatory tributes. Essentially “civic Scotland” sees in the Parliament a reflection of itself, and it likes what it sees.

Across those two decades Scotland has been governed by first Labour in coalition with the Lib Demsand then the SNP. The decline of Labour and rise of nationalism is much commented about. Less examined is the continuity of outlook regardless of party balance.

Whoever is in government there has been: a continued reliance on PFI, an undermining of local government, a further complication of the public service landscape through outsourcing and privatisation, and a far greater willingness to demand more powers for their institution than to fully utilise the powers they currently have. 

Leonard is aiming to change that. The contrast between his statement above and the SNP government could scarcely be greater.  

While Leonard talks of the necessity to build “a better society in a peaceful world on the strong foundation of a democratic economy” nationalist ministers in Edinburgh hand yet another massive contract (running lifeline ferry services to Orkney and Shetland) to serial leeches on the public purse Serco, and vote with the Tories to keep Scotland’s rail services privatised.

While the SNP is keen not to scare the big-business horses, there are signs that they are alert to the threat that a radicalised Labour Party poses.

The Scottish Parliament debated the final stage of the Climate Change Bill the day after Jeremy Corbyn’s conference speech. 

Until that point the SNP was committed to a carbon emissions cut of 70 per cent rather than the 75 per cent proposed by Scottish Labour. 

Overnight they changed their mind and adopted the Labour proposal. Typically they then went on to veto most of the Labour amendments to the Bill aimed at putting flesh on the bones of that target.

There has also been some talk from their Westminster leadership that they would be prepared to see Corbyn lead a temporary government in order to prevent a no-deal Brexit.  

The SNP is of course a huge fan of the EU. Apart from anything else, it has provided a marvellous excuse for knocking back progressive demands.  

When unions were arguing for the living wage to be a requirement in all public contracts, the response was: “We’d love to, but European rules…” But even given its Europhiliait would be a mistake to take its seeming contemplation of a caretaker Corbyn-led government at face value.

This is as much about positioning for the forthcoming election as it is about Brexit.  

With a faltering domestic agenda and, sensibly enough given a win looks far from certain, an unwillingness to fire the starting gun on another Indyref, the SNP knows it is vulnerable to a Corbyn challenge.  

It appears to have learned the lesson of the 2017 election. At the start of that campaign Nicola Sturgeon was describing Corbyn as being extreme. 

By the time it was over she was peddling the nonsense that the way to get people in Parliament who supported Corbyn’s politics was to vote SNP.  

Patent nonsense, as even the briefest scan of the SNP’sboasts about lowering business taxes shows.

Corbyn’s Labour worries the SNP. So, increasingly, will a Scottish Labour Party which is, in Leonard’s own words, “under new management.” 

While the nationalists lumber along with an agenda that stills sees markets and capitalist competition as common sense, Scottish Labour is, with policies based around public ownership and giving more power and opportunity to workers and tenants, squarely facing up to current challenges.  

The first 25 years of Holyrood, perhaps reflecting the New Labour era when it was established, were marked on all sides by a tendency to declare the mildest of reforms as the most radical of measures.  

In Leonard we finally have a senior politician in Scotland with a programme whose reality will match the rhetoric.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
PROPPING UP THE SNP: Scottish Green Party co-leaders Patrick
Voices of Scotland / 19 November 2024
19 November 2024
STEPHEN LOW details how the Scottish Greens’ retreat from full opposition to the Bill gives the SNP the opportunity to revive this toxic legislation and push through privatisation under the cover of popular reforms
Campaigners gather outside the Scottish Parliament at Holyro
Voices of Scotland / 9 April 2024
9 April 2024
They have done it again, laments STEPHEN LOW, as the Scottish government passes another intrusive Act, this time on ‘hate crimes,’ that seems so unworkable even those announcing it could not describe it accurately
WHO CARES: Confusion reigns over plans for a national care s
Features / 27 February 2024
27 February 2024
What the SNP-Green administration is asking politicians to do by voting on the new care service legislation, without being clear on what it even is, totally undermines Holyrood, writes STEPHEN LOW
FRUITY BEHAVIOUR: Scottish Health Secretary Michael Matheson
Voices of Scotland / 27 November 2023
27 November 2023
What could have been easily explained away and apologised for has instead ballooned into an embarrassing cover-up scandal for the Scottish political scene, reports STEPHEN LOW
Similar stories
Coins in a Saltire purse
Britain / 26 October 2024
26 October 2024
Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Scottish Labour Leader Anas Sar
Voices of Scotland / 14 October 2024
14 October 2024
Under Starmer and Sarwar, both the UK and Scottish Labour Parties are committed to the dogmas of neoliberalism – although signs are that resistance is growing, argues VINCE MILLS
Features / 17 September 2024
17 September 2024
The independence referendum’s youthful energy has dissipated, leaving Holyrood disconnected from voters as the constitutional question fades and Labour gains ground from a stagnant SNP, writes COLL MCCAIL
PROMISING BEGINNING? Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar with
Features / 6 July 2024
6 July 2024
STEPHEN LOW looks at an election in Scotland that, for the first time in a decade, wasn’t a fight about flags