Skip to main content
Understanding the dialectic that is at work
A valuable tool for comprehending which way the momentum is swinging the pendulum of British politics – and why, writes GAVIN O’TOOLE
T+K

The Death of Consensus: 100 Years of British Political Nightmares
by Phil Tinline
Hurst, £20

CONCEALED within the pages of The Death of Consensus is a revelation that invites the reader to think about British political history not in terms of events, but processes.

While the author insists from the outset that “none of this is to suggest that history is somehow circular,” that is precisely what his analysis of the “nightmares” upon which a dominant consensus is constructed implies.

The historical logic Phil Tinline unpicks certainly feels Hegelian and, by making the continuities and ruptures explicit, each period he examines becomes a product of contradictions inherent or implicit in the preceding stage. He has discerned a dialectic.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
art
Book Review / 10 December 2024
10 December 2024
GAVIN O’TOOLE explores the resistance expressed by central American artists to their own erasure by US imperialist policies 
chavez
Book Review / 28 August 2024
28 August 2024
Here’s an antidote to the Venezuela election-induced tantrums of Western elites. GAVIN O’TOOLE reviews it
norms
Book Review / 21 May 2024
21 May 2024
GAVIN O’TOOLE applauds an analysis of culture that explains why political conflicts today are focused more on values and identity than the economy and social questions
conflict resolution
Books / 15 March 2024
15 March 2024
GAVIN O’TOOLE observes that the call for a new international framework for conflict mediation is fatally marred by a partisan position on the Isreali-Gazan conflict
Similar stories
foster
Book Review / 15 January 2025
15 January 2025
Emphasising his continuous engagement in labour movement struggles, ALISTAIR FINDLAY salutes John Foster’s contribution as activist, strategist, intellectual and defender of the Morning Star
torres
Book Review / 29 December 2024
29 December 2024
GAVIN O’TOOLE recommends a book that examines the ‘invisible’ cultural cross-fertilisation that has bypassed the globalisation peddled by the West
art
Book Review / 10 December 2024
10 December 2024
GAVIN O’TOOLE explores the resistance expressed by central American artists to their own erasure by US imperialist policies 
XR
BenchMarx / 4 October 2024
4 October 2024
TOM HARDY demonstrates the power of creativity in gaining the upper hand during protests, and points to the irony of an exhibition celebrating the very activists who are now under arrest