Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
After Bataclan
ANGUS REID is astonished by a film of exceptional empathy that addresses a collective trauma
PTSD: Virginie Efira in Paris Memories

Paris Memories (15)
Directed by Alice Winocour


THE extraordinary benefit of having a national film culture is that this subtle and powerful medium can be used to process events of national significance for a mass audience and in an artistically satisfying and cathartic way.

But you’ll never have a national film culture until you reserve the majority of your screens for national product. That’s why it doesn’t exist in the UK (just go see what’s playing at your local Omni) but it does exist in France.

Paris Memories (a poor translation of Revoir Paris) is the kind of film that the French can make, and we cannot.

From the very start you know you are in the hands of a highly skilful storyteller. It just takes a few shots to establish Paris and a couple in its midst — he is a surgeon and she a translator from Russian. Mia (Virginie Efira) is younger, she’s beautiful and she’s disconcerted by her partner. They have a meal but he must leave, and she consoles herself with a glass of wine in a random bistro.

And then the gunfire starts.

It’s no surprise to find that the director’s brother was inside the Bataclan when the Islamists opened fire because this shocking experience is not just brilliantly handled but seen purely from the point of view of a victim of the attack who finds herself overwhelmed with PTSD.

There is so much indiscriminate killing that the mind blanks out the details (and the film cannot show what isn’t remembered) and then struggles obsessively to recover them.

This is a film, therefore, not only made for her brother with exceptional empathy and understanding, but also to address an event that is a collective national trauma.

When the survivors find themselves returning to the scene of the crime, with great reluctance and some agony they recognise that their lives cannot return to what they were before. They have an impossible task: to internalise the trauma and find some kind of redemption within it.

A teenage girl is searching for any trace or message from her murdered parents. One woman accuses another of selfish disregard for others, threatening to worsen any therapeutic outcome. And there was the accident of life-saving encounters with strangers who have gone missing.

The trauma has broken barriers of class and race and it is across this broken, unfamiliar landscape that Mia must journey in a performance of outstanding control and restrained emotional truth.

Her discoveries are astonishing and handled with a tact and authenticity that you never doubt. Alice Winocour has an extraordinary relish for every nuance of psychology and every slightest gesture in the course of this wise and life-affirming odyssey.

More than recommended — this is a masterpiece.

Out in cinemas today

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
STEADFAST: Orkney Friends of Palestine congragate in front of St Magnis Cathedral, Kirkwall [Pic: Angus Reid]
Britain / 28 May 2025
28 May 2025
Orkney
Music Festival / 28 May 2025
28 May 2025

ANGUS REID recommends a visit to an outstanding gathering of national and international folk musicians in the northern archipelago

CONFRONTING HOMOPHOBIA: (L) FCB Cadell, The Boxer, c.1924; (
Exhibition review / 21 March 2025
21 March 2025
While the group known as the Colourists certainly reinvigorated Scottish painting, a new show is a welcome chance to reassess them, writes ANGUS REID
BLOOD ON THE TRACKS: Xilun Sun as the mysterious interloper
Film of the Week: / 20 March 2025
20 March 2025
ANGUS REID recommends an exquisite drama about the disturbing impact of the one child policy in contemporary China
Similar stories
THE PERILS OF INTERNET DATING: (L) Ruaridh Mollica in Sebast
Cinema / 3 April 2025
3 April 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Sebastian, Four Mothers, Restless, and The Most Precious of Cargoes
BLOOD ON THE TRACKS: Xilun Sun as the mysterious interloper
Film of the Week: / 20 March 2025
20 March 2025
ANGUS REID recommends an exquisite drama about the disturbing impact of the one child policy in contemporary China
CANNY EYE: Photographer Martin Parr
Cinema / 20 February 2025
20 February 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews I Am Martin Parr, September Says, The Monkey, and The Gorge
(L) Bilal Hasna in Leyla; (R) Thomasin McKenzie and James in
Cinema / 21 November 2024
21 November 2024
A bucket-list of visuals, the unsung heroine of IVF, queer love in the City of London, and half a musical: The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Blink, Joy, Layla and Wicked