Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Parliament fixed?
DOUG NICHOLLS looks at the implications of the Fixed Term Parliament Act and Recall of MPs Act in the current crisis of democracy.

WHEN the Fixed Term Parliament Act was passed by the coalition government in 2011, many were so stunned in the headlights of the fierce austerity that we lost sight of the big negative effect the Act would have on our democracy.

No doubt at the time the Liberals were panicking that the Tories would dump them and wanted to prolong their unique moment of glory playing lapdog and putting the finishing touches to the destruction of public services and local democracy.

However, what the Act did was actually illiberal and dangerous. The Liberals love the EU and its centralising authoritarianism can be smelt in the Act as well.

The proponents of the Act said it took politics out of the calling of a general election, which is an odd concept for the most profound of political processes if ever there was one.

So the Act says there can only be a general election if a government reaches the end of its statutory term of office, if it itself decides to go to the people or if it faces a successful vote of no confidence passed by a parliamentary majority of two-thirds.

It all sounds quite reasonable perhaps until you apply its provisions to the current situation.

The British people have given Parliament the biggest mandate ever in our history to leave the EU. In calling the referendum, all parties agreed that Parliament would be bound by the result. It is partly irrelevant what the actual parties in Parliament do — their mandate is to take us out of the EU. That’s why the majority who voted for leave are so far patiently waiting. Patience might run out if Parliament proves incapable of getting us cleanly out of the EU.

Parliament has indeed voted to take us out of the EU on March 29 2019. That’s the default position if Parliament can’t agree a deal by then, we are still out. Any tinkering with this date would represent the deepest assault on democracy.

What happens then if a government which has rejected any cross-party involvement in negotiating our exit from the EU makes a mess of the withdrawal agreement? Just say hypothetically this were to happen!

And what, heaven forbid, if they were to make the mess with the full agreement of the EU bureaucrats who don’t want us to leave their club anyway and, even more unlikely surely, what if they were to propose an agreement to Parliament that looked more like staying in the EU than leaving in some key respects?

It’s beyond belief it could ever happen, but let’s say that government also deliberately agreed to surrender all parliamentary control over the key levers of economic and judicial power to the EU for two years without any influence over it. Not even Remainers voted for that. There’d be 33 million against such an imaginary deal.

And, stretching this impossible scenario even further, let’s say they made such an agreement at the latest possible time to put as much pressure on the timescale Parliament had previously agreed to. And let’s say, preposterously perhaps, they did so in the hope Brexit could be delayed for ever and it would seem so difficult to get out of the clutches of the EU no-one would ever bother again.

Well, unless those in Parliament opposing such hypothetically dastardly deeds have a two-thirds majority to remove the government, you can do bugger all about it. You can’t stamp your feet and call an election.

You then reach a scenario where Parliament agrees to abandon its authority more completely than ever to the EU and the government that leads to this abandonment of sovereignty can stay in power. You are left with no meaningful Parliament but a super-strong government gutted by the EU and hated by the British people.

Britain comes under the direct rule of the EU and it ends up with the DUP in effect arguing for home rule for the UK. Meanwhile, Sinn Fein MPs still don’t take up their seats in Westminster to help save us from ourselves alone and are content with their seats in Brussels to make Ireland a wholly owned subsidiary of the EU. And let’s not forget the Scots Nats preferring to be governed by Jean Claude Junker than Jeremy Corbyn.

You couldn’t make it up and might get angry about it. So you consult the Recall of MPs Act 2015 — after all, these MPs are accountable to us aren’t they, so perhaps we can get rid of them.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer (centre front) stands with L
Features / 16 July 2024
16 July 2024
DOUG NICHOLLS, chair of the think tank Rebuild Britain, encourages creative engagement with the new government on economic matters particularly
Jacques Delors, President of the European Comission, address
Features / 30 December 2023
30 December 2023
DOUG NICHOLLS, former general secretary of the General Federation of Trade Unions and lifelong campaigner against the European Union, reflects on the recent death of one of the main architects of the EU
U.S. President Joe Biden, right, and Chinese President Xi Ji
Features / 16 November 2022
16 November 2022
The GFTU has been running education courses on what is really happening in China and the US, Doug Nicholls reflects on some of the learnings and the importance of the recent US-China talks in Bali
Community organisations Acorn and Southwark Defend Council h
Features / 19 October 2022
19 October 2022
In the second of a two-part feature for TUC week, DOUG NICHOLLS, general secretary of the General Federation of Trade Unions discusses the underestimated strength of community organisations and the value of a new working relationship with trade unions
Similar stories
Majority members out campaigning in Newcastle [Pic: Majority]
Durham Miners’ Gala 2025 / 12 July 2025
12 July 2025

JAMIE DRISCOLL explains how his group, Majority, plans to empower working people to empower themselves

Re your message in #nujchapel:  If we website looks like shit, no-one is going to take us seriously, or be inclined to subscribe - that's why I think we have to prioritise the way it looks, especially when the site (editorial-wise) is largely working.  When it comes to the issues you mentioned to me the other day (word count, curly quotes, bylines), there are quick and easy work arounds for them (copy and paste text into BBedit, Word, Pages, wordcount.com, etc. Leave curly quotes, bylines, etc to the web de
Democracy / 2 July 2025
2 July 2025

From Gaza complicity to welfare cuts chaos, Starmer’s baggage accumulates, and voters will indeed find ‘somewhere else’ to go — to the Greens, nationalists, Lib Dems, Reform UK or a new, working-class left party, writes NICK WRIGHT

ET OFF LIGHTLY: Finance Secretary Shona Robison announcing t
Aw That / 1 February 2025
1 February 2025
Attempts at haggling to win a deal over the Scottish Budget still leave public services short-changed, writes MATT KERR
TUC Congress 2024 / 10 September 2024
10 September 2024
Speaking to Elizabeth Short, SARAH WOOLLEY explains her union’s push for anonymous harassment reporting, an end to NDAs that protect abusive managers in food giants like McDonald’s — and why climate change is a baker’s issue