Skip to main content
Indigestible unthink

ALEX HALL is disgusted by the misuse of ‘emotional narratives’ to justify uninformed geo-political prejudice

Dominique Moisi at the Festival of Economics in Trento, Italy, 2013 [Pic: Niccolo Caranti/CC]

The Triumph of Emotions: Geopolitics in an Age of Resentment, Anger and Fear
Dominique Moisi, Polity, £20

 

THE title of this book might lead you to believe it covers some interesting subject matter. Perhaps a psychological assessment of various world leaders? Maybe an examination of atrocity propaganda effects on different nations? Possibly how racial hatred is expressed in international relations? Alas, its none of these things. It’s Mr Moisi’s internal emotive reactions in written form.

These gut reactions are staunchly pro-Western. They are also, to Moisi, completely self-evident. A critical analysis of sources or scholarship is notable only by its absence, and instead we read a recitation of ruling-class propaganda narratives. Moisi examines a subject by asking himself how he feels about it and then tells us. Emotions really do triumph here.

Thankfully there are only four chapters. These cover the present Russia-Ukraine war, the global South, global East (a one-off definition for this particular work) and the global West. Consulting the imagination for emotional reactions gives a recognisable Fox News narrative to what is returned.

Donate to the Fighting Fund
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Interview / 9 July 2023
9 July 2023
JOE SOLO tells ALEX HALL about life as a working-class artist, and the meaning of his new anthem These Are My People
Similar stories
DODGY DUO: Pleased as Punch Peter Mandelson and Keir Starmer
Features / 7 March 2025
7 March 2025
You’ll never guess why a quick peace in Ukraine might be in the ambassador to Washington’s interests, writes SOLOMON HUGHES. Actually, of course you will – he stands to make a lot of money from his business links to Russia
From left, European Council President Antonio Costa, Ukraine
Features / 7 March 2025
7 March 2025
Behind the war fever, there is more than just the alleged threat of Russia; economic decline and the struggle for geopolitical dominance play a crucial role in the increasing militarisation of our continent, writes MARC VANDEPITTE
DANGEROUS IDEOLOGUE: Anne Applebaum addresses the Central Eu
Books / 9 October 2024
9 October 2024
ALEX HALL puts on asbestos gloves to handle a simple-minded ideological work of the ruling class
INTERNATIONALISTS: NEU contingent at a Palestine rally
Features / 22 June 2024
22 June 2024
Why trade unionists should build the movement for peace in Palestine and Ukraine, posits JOE WILSON