Skip to main content
The Musician: A Horror Opera for Children
Well-staged prequel to The Pied Piper lacks emotional charge

CONOR MITCHELL’S children's play The Musician is a prequel to The Pied Piper of Hamelin, known to most through the version by the Brothers Grimm and the poetry of Robert Browning.

Written, directed, composed and choreographed by Mitchell for the Belfast Ensemble, it's also an introduction to operatic style and convention, challenging children to embrace the power of music while also engaging in what is, effectively, a morality tale.

The story is of a boy alone in the world. Into his path steps a strange musician, taunting him with haunting melodies which entrance the boy. He learns to play the stranger’s flute-like pipe and, as his power and musicality grow, so his kind nature is consumed and he responds to the unkindness of others with harsh and devastating consequences.

The cast have fully trained operatic voices and the socially distanced orchestra — visibly arrayed around the raked stage — fill the air with strange and wondrous chords and sequences. Most of the words are sung and the whole production is impressively stylised, creating a pantomime effect in which exuberantly colourful costumes illuminate a stage constantly transformed by light.

As a lesson in the technical brilliance of theatre and the power of music, The Musician succeeds. But as a drama fit to hold the imagination of children it is less effective — something at its heart is absent. We don’t experience empathy for the boy, the story is awkwardly fabricated and the power of the music is limited because the innocence it overthrows is never effectively established.

Sarah Richmond, Matthew Cavan, Rebecca Murphy, Paul Carey Jones and Maeve McGreevy sing and perform with excellent precision, but keeping children fully engaged may be a struggle if, perhaps, their hearts remain unswayed. The play falls short of the brilliance of the original Pied Piper, with which, for empathy, narrative purpose, language and demonic enchantment, it must of necessity be compared.

Happily, though, this is theatre that avoids the common sin of talking down to children and its music, conducted by Tom Brady, is rich and sophisticated.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
The cast in Regarding Shelley / Pic: Upstairs at the Gatehouse
Theatre / 23 May 2025
23 May 2025

MARY CONWAY is disappointed by a play that presents Shelley as polite and conventional man who lives a chocolate box, cottagey life

5ht
Theatre review / 21 May 2025
21 May 2025

MARY CONWAY is stirred by a play that explores masculinity every bit as much as it penetrates addiction

deal
Theatre review / 14 May 2025
14 May 2025

In this production of David Mamet’s play, MARY CONWAY misses the essence of cruelty that is at the heart of the American deal

builder
Theatre review / 2 May 2025
2 May 2025

MARY CONWAY is disappointed by a star-studded adaptation of Ibsen’s play that is devoid of believable humanity

Similar stories
Matchless: Samuel Barnett and Victoria Yeates in Ben and Imo / Pic: Ellie Kurttz
Theatre Review / 28 April 2025
28 April 2025

MARY CONWAY relishes two matchless performers and a masterclass in tightly focused wordplay

Ineza
Interview / 26 February 2025
26 February 2025
CHRIS SEARLE speaks to Rwanda-born jazz vocalist INEZA
FRIEND OR ANEMONE? Liana Cottrill as The Little Mermaid
Theatre Review / 12 December 2024
12 December 2024
SIMON PARSONS is swept away on the running tide of a dynamic new version of Hans Christian Andersen’s fairy tale
Theatre review / 29 August 2024
29 August 2024
PETER MASON is enchanted by a unique take on the Oscar Wilde favourite delivered through the ancient form of marionettes