Skip to main content
Bee yourself
MARTIN HALL admires a remarkable film that concentrates on the human impact of gender dysphoria
Sofia Otero in 20,000 Species of Bees, a role for which he became the first child actor to win Berlin's Silver Bear

20,000 Species of Bees (12A)
Directed by Urresola Solaguren

 

 

THIS is an impressive debut from Urresola Solguren. 

She tackles the tricky subject of gender identity with skill and sensitivity, helped by strong performances from Sofia Otero as Aitor/Cocoo/Lucia, Patricia Lopez Arnaiz as sculptor and mother Ane, and Ane Gaberain as grandmother Lourdes. 

Otero won the Silver Bear for Best Leading Performance at the Berlin Film Festival, the first child actor to do so.

The film comments throughout on borders, mirrors/glass, lines and boundaries and on what is noticed and what is not. Lourdes seeing that Coco (the indeterminate name Aitor goes by throughout much of the first two thirds of the film) wants to become Lucia is a mirror for her not noticing that her artist husband was causing a scandal when photographing the town’s young girls years earlier, and the problems it caused for Ane.

The film begins with the crossing of a border, from Bayonne where Ane lives with her husband and three children, to her mother’s house in Laudio/Llodia in the Spanish Basque country. We see Coco looking through back windows and into mirrors throughout. 

Ane’s sculpting parallels her father’s historically, and Coco’s attempted self-construction in the present. The past/the present and the male and the female are placed next to each other, sometimes in opposition, sometimes blurring. 

Then, there are the bees. The hives are where Coco seems most at ease, and where Lourdes and he bond (I am using the male pronoun as that is what the film does until the final section). As there are many types of bees, so there are many types of boys and girls. 

After spending time with Coco at the hives, it is Lourdes who encourages Ane to let him be treated as a girl. 

Ane’s view throughout the film has been that “there’s no girls’ or boys’ stuff”. She has attempted to teach her children that they can be whatever they want while remaining within their observed sex but that is not enough for Coco, who wonders if “something went wrong in the womb.”

Things come to a head in the final 20 minutes, when Ane decides to let Coco wear a dress to a family christening. I’ll avoid plot spoilers and simply say that the question of proper nouns is key to the film’s denouement.

The film manages to do something very well: to avoid the debates around sex and gender by focusing on the human and the concrete reality of the topic for one family.

Out in cinemas on Friday

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
European Union flags wave in the wind as pedestrians walk by
Features / 25 July 2024
25 July 2024
As Starmer hints at closer ties, MARTIN HALL warns of the dangers of creeping alignment and calls for a renewed socialist case for independence from Brussels, especially over the EU’s constraints on economic planning
Meeting of the Petrograd soviet in 1917
Book Review / 13 August 2023
13 August 2023
MARTIN HALL steps gingerly through a work of French political theory, picking out the gems
Discussion / 1 November 2021
1 November 2021
Until such time as a new parliamentary vehicle for the working class emerges, socialists should continue to vote Labour, argues MARTIN HALL
Features / 11 September 2019
11 September 2019
Why did Labour go from from a ‘People’s Brexit’ position to a politically incoherent Remain-sympathetic fudge – and how can we stop the impending disaster, asks MARTIN HALL
Similar stories
Film of the Week: / 27 February 2025
27 February 2025
MARIA DUARTE recommends an homage to the iconic showgirl that understands them as working-class women 
Niousha Akhshi in The Seed of the Sacred Fig
Film of the Week: / 6 February 2025
6 February 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE is enthralled by a complex thriller, but advises caution in accepting its depiction of reality
STUNNING: Ethan Herisse and Brandon Turner in Nickel Boys
Cinema / 10 January 2025
10 January 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Nickel Boys, Bank of Dave 2: The Loan Ranger, Babygirl, and Maria
CLAIMING HER PLACE: (L) Maud Sulter, Self-portrait, 2001-2,
Exhibition Review / 10 December 2024
10 December 2024
JOE JACKSON explores how growing up black amid ‘the quiet racism of Scotland’ shaped the art and politics of Maud Sulter