Skip to main content
Advertise Buy the paper Contact us Shop Subscribe Support us
‘There is such a thing as ineradicable homosexuality’, Harry Whyte, letter to Stalin, 1934
MATTHEW HAWKINS treads warily through the symphonic history of a subject that our present understanding can only obscure

Forbidden Desire in Early Modern Europe, 1400 - 1750
Noel Malcolm
OUP, £25

THE lauded historian Noel Malcolm begins Forbidden Desire in Early Modern Europe by relating an account of how, in 1558, in the household of the Venetian embassy in Istanbul, two young male pages were repeatedly seen flirting and kissing. Other downstairs workers didn’t actually seem to mind, and some were diverted and amused. Those in charge were concerned enough to document and suppress the blandishment, as they didn’t want the household to be seen as resembling local Muslim equivalents, where convention condoned acts of sodomy – or was this just a smear?

Disquisition follows on a grand symphonic scale and the reader is launched into myriad calibrated thoughts. Why are men so strange? Where does recreation end and denigration begin? Is it illuminating or alienating to peer at carnality through a prism of historical and cultural shifts? 

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Fiction / 7 January 2025
7 January 2025
MATTHEW HAWKINS is drawn into the everyday lives of women and girls in Muslim communities in southern India
Books / 25 October 2024
25 October 2024
MATTHEW HAWKINS admires a writer with the gumption and wit to extend a transformative experience of autism to the reader
Follow the movement / 19 August 2024
19 August 2024
MATTHEW HAWKINS applauds two evocative new productions that have premiered at the Edinburgh Fringe before touring nationwide
Follow the Movement / 14 August 2024
14 August 2024
MATTHEW HAWKINS savours the brilliant dynamism of Brazilian contemporary dance, and Leicester’s own virtuoso of Indian dervishery
Similar stories
Boxing / 30 August 2024
30 August 2024
JOHN WIGHT writes on The Greatest's solidarity with the people of Palestine
Features / 19 June 2024
19 June 2024
Is the United Nations finally recognising that the sex trade is a form of exploitation and a breach of human rights? LUBA FEIN welcomes a new report which suggests that might be the case
Exhibition review / 23 April 2024
23 April 2024
LEO BOIX recommends a refreshing, non-Western and subversive look at what it means to be LGBTQI+ in Morocco
Book Review / 29 February 2024
29 February 2024
SONYA ANDERMAHR finds a voice worth listening to in the candid account of a trans woman who came to question gender identity politics