Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Cameron faces first defeat over Sunday trading hours plan

DAVID CAMERON’S government was defeated in the Commons for the first time yesterday over plans to wreck Britain’s “social fabric” and workers’ weekends by turning Sundays into another shopping bonanza.

A rebellion of more than 20 Tories helped scupper a plan to let councils set Sunday opening hours — which was not in the party’s manifesto. An amendment to remove the plan from the Enterprise Bill was won by a thumping 317 to 286 votes.

“I warned the government that unless they pulled their plans then they would face a public and humiliating defeat on the floor of the House of Commons,” said Labour shadow business secretary Angla Eagle.

“That is exactly what we have delivered.”

Communities Minister Brandon Lewis bungled a last minute bid to avoid the mutiny, attempting to make an amendment that would see the plans piloted in 12 areas and debated again by MPs in a year’s time. But former Tory defence minister Gerald Howarth said the concessions made “the back of a fag packet look sophisticated.”

Speaker John Bercow torpedoed the government escape plan by refusing to put Mr Lewis’s amendment to a vote. MPs from all parties quoted a survey conducted by shopworkers’ union Usdaw that showed 91 per cent of staff in large shops were opposed to the extension of Sunday trading hours.

Labour MP David Lammy asked: “Why is it that in this country this government thinks that we should put the free market first above everything else?”

SNP MP Hannah Bardell warned that low-paid staff could lose overtime payments and said she was “not prepared to gamble with the pay packets of some of Scotland and the UK’s lowest-paid workers.”

Small shops are already allowed to open all hours on Sundays, but high street giants and out-of-town stores are limited to opening between 10am and 6pm on a Sunday.

Opponents warn the new rules would extend that for up to six hours. The government, which has a slender majority of 13, has not lost a vote in the Commons since last May’s election. 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Britain / 14 August 2016
14 August 2016
No-one left behind with schools run NHS-style
Britain / 14 August 2016
14 August 2016
Britain / 12 August 2016
12 August 2016
Court blocks 130,000 from voting
Britain / 12 August 2016
12 August 2016
Similar stories
A man carrying bags in the Broadmead shopping area of Bristo
Britain / 23 December 2024
23 December 2024
A Universal Credit sign on a door of a job centre plus in ea
TUC Congress 2024 / 10 September 2024
10 September 2024
We need a proper social security system that supports families and provides a proper safety net, writes PADDY LILLIS, calling for the Labour government to lift the cruel two-child benefit cap