Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Sturgeon: If Labour wants us it has to ditch the cuts

SCOTTISH First Minister Nicola Sturgeon put the cat among the pigeons yesterday, declaring austerity wrong and saying its end was the price of backing Labour in a minority government.

In a speech in London the Scottish National Party leader said Chancellor George Osborne’s economic policy had “failed even on its own terms.”

Its mistakes had cost every single person in the UK £2,500 in rising national debt, she said, adding: “And now, when the evidence tells us that austerity hasn’t worked, the UK government is now telling us is that we need even more of it.”

The SNP leader predicted that current plans to slash Britain’s debts would have “severe” consequences for household debt.

“Most of the economic growth the UK government expects will come from household consumption,” she said.

“But in a time of low wage increases and high inequality, this can only happen if household spending rises more quickly than household incomes.

“That will lead to an increase in debt.”

She said the SNP would be pushing for a “more rational economic policy.”

Debt should be reduced, said Ms Sturgeon, but “more gradually” than proposed.

“If you limited real-terms growth in departmental spending to 0.5 per cent each year, it would reduce debt as a share of GDP in every year from 2016-17.

“It would also permit — compared to current UK government plans — a further £180 billion of investment across the UK over the next four years,” she claimed.

But experts warned that her “anti-austerity” alternative fell short of the action needed to stimulate the economy.

Socialist Economic Bulletin analyst Michael Burke said she was “barking up the right tree” but “0.5 per cent of anything isn’t very much.”

“Nicola Sturgeon is right to say austerity has failed and should be abandoned,” but “what seems to be proposed falls way short,” he said.

“Under Gordon Brown there was a moderate recovery fuelled by a temporary increase in public investment.

“The Tory-led coalition cut that by 2 per cent of GDP.”

Mr Burke said: “You would need to restore that cut on a sustained basis simply to get a moderate but sustained economic upturn.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Features / 4 November 2016
4 November 2016
The tabloid headlines surrounding benefits claimants are little more than fiction, write RUTH HUNT and NICK DILWORTH
Sport / 3 September 2016
3 September 2016
Roger Domeneghetti recommends a new documentary on Bobby Moore
Britain / 26 February 2015
26 February 2015
Britain / 26 February 2015
26 February 2015
Similar stories
Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves speaks at a reception for British and EU businesses in Downing Street, London, May 19, 2025
Austerity / 31 May 2025
31 May 2025

Exempting military expenditure from austerity while slashing welfare represents a fundamental misallocation of resources that guarantees continued decline, argues MICHAEL BURKE

Protesters show placards as Chancellor Rachel Reeves is abou
Features / 29 March 2025
29 March 2025
While slashing welfare and public services, Labour’s spring statement delivers a bonanza for death-dealing bomb merchants. We now see the true and terrible face of austerity 2.0, writes MICHAEL BURKE
Then SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon with then husband Peter Murr
Britain / 12 March 2025
12 March 2025
Features / 3 November 2024
3 November 2024
In the first of two articles, ROBERT GRIFFITHS argues that despite a parliamentary majority, Labour’s timid Budget fails to seize a historic opportunity and lacks the ambition needed to address Britain’s deep social and economic crises