Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
The Welkin, National Theatre London
Riveting and original exploration of women's lives in mid-18th century England
COMMANDING: Maxine Peake (second right) in The Welkin

THE MONOCHROMATIC, yet stylish, opening scene of a dozen women isolated in their daily drudgery in Lucy Kirkwood’s new play initially appears to be heading towards well-worn territory — the trial format of Twelve Angry Men.

But those brought together are a “jury of matrons” and their role is to decide whether the guilty woman in front of them is pregnant. If she is, she escapes the noose for transportation instead.

With only the nominal supervision of a muted court official, this eclectic group is temporarily released from daily oppressive routines to freely argue another woman’s fate.

Prejudices abound over the foul-mouthed and unsympathetic accused woman Sally Poppy, played with naked hostility by Ria Zmitrowicz, and it is left to Maxine Peake’s commanding presence as Lizzy Luke, the local no-nonsense midwife, to fight her corner.

Her passionate and essentially liberal approach to the woman’s guilt is in stark contrast to the values displayed by many of the others.

Haydn Gwynne’s aloof presence as a supposed well-to-do stranger to the town offers a focal point to the group set against Sally and she’s supported by Cecilia Noble’s outspokenly dismissive and amusingly pretentious Emma. Among the waverers are Dawn Sievewright’s independent, strong-willed Kitty and June Watson as the older matriarch Sarah.

Although their opinions and individual circumstances divide them, it is their unifying warmth as a sisterhood bonded by childbirth that unites them and generates much of the passion and unexpected humour.

James MacDonald directs an outstanding cast, clearly revelling in their strongly differentiated roles, and unites them in fleetingly recognisable tableaux of 18th-century life.

Bunny Christie’s diverse and atmospheric sets, imaginatively framed to create differing perspectives, and Carolyn Downing’s immersive background soundscapes add to the style and substance of this excellent production.

The twists and revelations maintain suspense throughout but they are far more than functional elements of a courtroom drama.

Set in 1759, on the predicted eve of the reappearance of Halley’s comet and the sense of growing scientific and financial empowerment, the women’s interactions reveal their strength and fortitude in the face of an oppressive male-dominated world.

The outcome does not forsake convention. But it moves beyond it to a haunting climax, as original as it is memorable.

Runs until May 23, box office: nationaltheatre.org.uk

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
IMPASSIONED: Phoebe Thomas and Matt Whitchurch / Pic: Ellie Kurttz
Theatre review / 25 May 2025
25 May 2025

SIMON PARSONS is taken by a thought provoking and intelligent play performed with great sensitivity

Terrors
Theatre review / 16 May 2025
16 May 2025

SIMON PARSONS is gripped by a psychological thriller that questions the the power of the state over vulnerable individuals

CLASS AND SEXUALITY: Sesley Hope and Synnove Karlsen in Laura Lomas’s The House Party / Pic: Ikin Yum
Theatre Review / 24 April 2025
24 April 2025

SIMON PARSONS applauds an imaginative and absorbing updating of Strindberg’s classic

Lizzie Watts and Andre Squire in Jane Upton’s (the) Woman
Theatre review / 19 February 2025
19 February 2025
SIMON PARSONS is discomfited by an unflichingly negative portrait of motherhood and its trials
Similar stories
Lizzie Watts and Andre Squire in Jane Upton’s (the) Woman
Theatre review / 19 February 2025
19 February 2025
SIMON PARSONS is discomfited by an unflichingly negative portrait of motherhood and its trials
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING: The cast of The Grapes of Wrath
Theatre review / 1 August 2024
1 August 2024
PAUL DONOVAN admires a brave attempt to stage John Steinbeck’s epic tale of poverty-stricken 1930s America
TRICKS OF MEMORY: Khalid Abdalla, Eileen Walsh and the Mnemo
Theatre review / 5 July 2024
5 July 2024
WILL STONE gets a little lost in a play about memory that misremembers another production of itself