Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
The Sugar Syndrome, Orange Tree Theatre Richmond upon Thames
Edgy exploration of damaged relationships in the early days of the internet
DESPERATE RELATIONSHIP: Tim (John Hollingworth) and Dani (Jessica Rhodes)

THIS disturbing Lucy Prebble play has not been seen since its debut at the Royal Court 17 years ago.

 

Understandable, since the subject matter is so uncomfortable that any artistic director might baulk at putting it on, and credit is due to the Orange Tree for staging a revival. It deserves full houses every night.

 

While the play itself is electrifying, the acting from the outstanding cast of four generates its own static charge, creating an atmosphere that occasionally makes the hair stand on end.

 

Jessica Rhodes makes a sensational professional debut as Dani, a reckless 17-year-old with an eating disorder who makes contact via an internet chatroom with two men.

 

The 22-year-old Lewis (Ali Barouti) sees himself as her potential boyfriend but the considerably older Tim (John Hollingworth) turns out, as she suspects, to be a paedophile.

 

Meeting up with both suitors separately, Tim is the one she prefers to engage with and the pair begin to develop a desperate and seemingly supportive relationship, in which they try to explore ways of understanding and controlling each other’s destructive urges.

 

But it turns out that there are limits to how far they can progress and, in a raw and traumatic final scene, Dani is forced to understand that even though it’s easy to bury yourself in abstraction, there’s no hiding place from a brutal real world or personal responsibility.

 

In Rebecca Brower’s minimalist set, the subdued and soothing lights of the internet encase brighter, starker realities, from Jessica’s home-with-no-comforts to Tim’s ready-to-run flat with boxed possessions.

 

They convey the bleak and disappointing worlds that confront each character, including Dani’s worried mother (Alexandra Gilbreath), whose failing marriage underpins the action.

 

The protagonists are by turns innocent and worldly-wise, vulnerable and controlling or sensitive and manipulative, while sympathies switch from one to the other as events unfold.

 

In the end it’s tricky to decide who, if anyone, has a proper handle on the real world. Pinpointing the truth was difficult enough even in the dial-up internet world first portrayed by this play back in 2003. These days, of course, it's even harder.

 

Runs until February 22, box office: orangetreetheatre.co.uk

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
flam
Dance / 30 May 2025
30 May 2025

PETER MASON is wowed (and a little baffled) by the undeniably ballet-like grace of flamenco

IT'S JUST NOT CRICKET: Protesters demonstrate outside Lord's Cricket Ground in London, on February 25 2025, against England playing Afghanistan in a Champions Trophy match, as female participation in sport has effectively been outlawed in Afghanistan since the Tailban returned to power in 2021
Books / 25 May 2025
25 May 2025

PETER MASON is surprised by the bleak outlook foreseen for cricket’s future by the cricketers’ bible

(L) Mudlark kneels on a rocky shore, collecting objects; (R) Medieval pilgrim badge. Pics © London Museum
Exhibitions / 22 April 2025
22 April 2025

PETER MASON is enthralled by an assembly of objects, ancient and modern, that have lain in the mud of London’s river

POWER-DRESSING: Miriam Grace Edwards as Mary in Mrs Presiden
Theatre Review / 5 February 2025
5 February 2025
PETER MASON applauds a thought-provoking study of the relationship between a grieving woman and her photographer
Similar stories
Matchless: Samuel Barnett and Victoria Yeates in Ben and Imo / Pic: Ellie Kurttz
Theatre Review / 28 April 2025
28 April 2025

MARY CONWAY relishes two matchless performers and a masterclass in tightly focused wordplay

Gaelic Warrior ridden by Patrick Mullins on their way to winning the Brooklands Golden Miller Chronograph Bowl Chase on day one of the Randox Grand National Festival at Aintree Racecourse, Liverpool. Picture date: Thursday April 3, 2025
Horse racing / 25 April 2025
25 April 2025

Farringdon looks ahead to this weekend's races 

(L) Shaun Evans as Kazan and Michael Aloni as Miller In Davi
Interview / 11 October 2024
11 October 2024
MAYER WAKEFIELD speaks to playwright David Edgar about the political analysis that underlies his two new plays
Jasmine Blackorow (Miss Bauer) and Michael Aloni (Art) in Da
Theatre Review / 26 September 2024
26 September 2024
MARY CONWAY feels the contemporary resonance of a new play set amid the manic and self-destructive patriotism of the McCarthy era