Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Can we finally bust the myths about migration?
From misunderstanding the net gain made from foreign students to the need for workers to plug the gaps created by our ageing population, anti-immigration tropes need to be confronted, writes PAUL DONOVAN

THE national obsession with immigration in this country is often difficult to fathom.

The latest furore concerned net immigration figures of 745,000.

The throwing around of such figures is misleading, pulling together refugees, economic migrants, students and others in a headline figure that Daily Mail leader writers can then fulminate about.

The small boats coming across the channel have become a focus of government policy — despite the relatively small numbers involved.

The dehumanising approach of politicians generally explains much of the failure of policy. Crazy schemes like basically trying to scare already frightened refugees into not coming because they could end up in Rwanda, rather than on the gold-paved streets of Britain, make no sense.

There is much talk of targeting the traffickers but they are just an effect of the problem. The causes behind the creation of these refugees are things like war and environmental degradation. Address these causes, if the small boats are such an issue.

Maybe, a bit of circumspection on Britain’s own role in wars, such as Iraq and Afghanistan. Britain is also a major arms seller. Also, Britain’s increasingly backward policies on the climate crisis.

The hierarchy of suffering is another thing difficult to fathom, with Britain having a far more welcoming attitude to those coming from say Ukraine and Hong Kong compared to Afghanistan and Iraq.

The mindless attitude to economic migration is even more difficult to understand. In a country with an ageing population and labour shortages, migrant labour is essential to fill the gaps and keep the economy going.

The statistics show migrants add to revenues, they are not a drain. True, infrastructural support needs to be provided but the extra tax coming in from migrant workers should meet this need. Migrant workers should not of course be allowed to undercut indigenous workers’ pay, terms and conditions.

Also, why are asylum-seekers not allowed to work while they are here, especially given that they can be waiting years to have their claims heard?

Possibly, the most ludicrous target in the migrant wars are foreign students. Further education is one of the few growth areas in this country — it is largely kept going by fees from foreign students but some in government want to stop them coming. Utterly ludicrous. As with many other categories, foreign students are mostly only here for a limited time, so are a net gain for the economy.

In fact, taking economic migrants and students as indicative categories, the large number coming in is an indicator of a healthy economy. Migrants come to get work or learn, not, as the tabloid myth would have us believe, to take benefits.

The unhealthy obsession with migration threatens to do great damage to the economic and cultural fabric of society. The categorising of migration as “a problem” helps build fear.

The opposition to migration is driven by fear-based racism. This is aided by a wilful, racist misuse of data by some media to drive sales of their own products.

This national racism-driven obsession with migration helped bring about Brexit (something ironically that has cut the overall wealth of the country and helped create skill shortages). It will do more damage if right-wing politicians and their media megaphones are allowed to continue creating unfounded fears and divisions in society.

What is needed is a proper recognition of the pluses and minuses of migration. There then needs to be a humane, efficient and welcoming system developed for all the different categories of migrants. The backlogs need to be cleared. Using people’s lives as political footballs is not acceptable.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
SUPPING WITH THE DEVIL: Stanley Townsend (Mr Parks), Ivanno
Theatre review / 21 March 2025
21 March 2025
PAUL DONOVAN applauds a timely play that explores the resonances of McCarthyite nationalism in today’s US
Newcastle United's Bruno Guimaraes after the Premier League
Men's Football / 12 March 2025
12 March 2025
Men’s football / 16 February 2025
16 February 2025
SEEING EYE TO EYE: US President Meeting with Pope John Paul
Book Review / 13 February 2025
13 February 2025
PAUL DONOVAN is fascinated by an account of the long history of Catholic Church’s involvement in espionage
Similar stories
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer speaking during a press conference on the Immigration White Paper, May 12, 2025
Politics / 31 May 2025
31 May 2025

DIANE ABBOTT MP argues that Labour’s proposals contained in the recent white paper won’t actually bring down immigration numbers or win support from Reform voters — but they will succeed in making politics more nasty and poisonous 
 

ANGER GROWS: Protesters demonstrate in Dover against migrant
Features / 10 April 2025
10 April 2025
The left must confront both far-right bigotry and the undeniable problems the exploitation of migrant workers by the ruling class creates — but there are few lessons from the global left on how to strike this balance, laments NICK WRIGHT
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer leads a roundtable discussio
Editorial: / 31 March 2025
31 March 2025