Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Voices of Scotland: State of the Nation(alists)

THESE are difficult times for centrists. Stunned by Brexit, their reactions are confused and inconsistent.

On a wider political front, faced with multiple and overlapping crises in public services, wages and housing, they offer only managerial solutions where radical action is called for. Then they wonder why the tide seems to be flowing in Jeremy Corbyn’s direction.  Few groupings exemplify this more than the Scottish National Party.

People can be forgiven for failing to notice the SNP contribution during last week’s Brexit farrago. In fairness, it didn’t add much to the general debate, but it did outline some of the confusion and difficulties the SNP finds itself in.

Ian Blackford MP, the former investment banker leading the nationalists in Westminster, opined that, in the event of either a no deal Brexit or one which left the UK out of the customs union and single market, the SNP government in Edinburgh “would have a conversation with the people of Scotland and we would be asking the parliament in Edinburgh to put in place the mechanisms for a second referendum.”

As threats go, this one is bizarre. Let’s try to follow the logic here. The SNP wants the UK to remain in the single market and customs union.

To try to put pressure on the government it is saying that, if that doesn’t happen, it will call another independence referendum (Indyref2 as we say in these parts).

Staying in the single market and customs union should therefore prevent Indyref2, but the SNP also separately say they want Indyref2  — and independence obviously.

If Mr Blackford is to be believed, however, Indyref2 goes off the agenda if the UK stays in the single market and customs union. This is every bit as confused as it sounds and means the SNP European and constitutional goals are mutually incompatible.

The confusion doesn’t end there. In March this year, the SNP put a motion through the Scottish Parliament instructing the Scottish government to make arrangements to allow a referendum that would “most appropriately be between the autumn of 2018, when there is clarity over the outcome of the Brexit negotiations, and around the point at which the UK leaves the EU in spring 2019.” So even if Ms May, assuming her survival as PM, delivers the Brexit Mr Blackford seeks, if the SNP doesn’t proceed with Indyref2, it will be defying the will of the Scottish Parliament.

Meanwhile the party’s domestic agenda appears to be running out of steam. There has been little legislation introduced into the Scottish Parliament since the SNP won its third term of government in 2016. A mere five Bills, with two of those — the child protection “named person scheme” and proposed cuts to air passenger duty — both running into technical difficulties and proving hugely controversial.

Changes to school governance undermining local authorities have had to be withdrawn. NHS vacancies are at record highs.  A widely supported integration of health and social care isn’t delivering the improvement in services hoped for as it isn’t being sufficiently resourced to do so.

This week, the Scottish government produces its budget. The big question here is what it will do to offset the £200 million or so cuts to its spending budget from Westminster.

Previously cuts were simply passed on, mostly to local government. Indeed the SNP Scottish government managed to make cuts to councils last year even when its own budget stayed still.

This year it’s expected some use will be made of devolved income tax powers. No-one though is expecting an attempt to shift the balance of wealth and power.

“We are proud of our entrepreneurs and appreciate that the risks they take in order to innovate require investment,”  Finance Secretary Derek MacKay assures businesses, promising a "future-proofed, forward-thinking Scottish economy.”

As if this isn’t New Labour-sounding enough, former Scottish Labour ministers Susan Deacon and Wendy Alexander have been recruited in recent weeks to Scottish government bodies on policing and the economy.This does not look like a government that has new ideas.

Scottish Labour meanwhile has elected Richard Leonard as leader.

He campaigned explicitly on moving beyond the managerialism that has defined Scotland’s post-devolution politics.

His pitch is that serious problems require radical solutions. His emphasis so far has been extraparliamentary and anti-austerity. 

The contest in Scottish politics is shaping up to be between the party that says it will be “Stronger for Scotland” and the party that will be stronger for Scotland’s workers.

Expect it to become increasingly obvious who radicals and progressives ought to be backing in that fight.  
 

 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
PROPPING UP THE SNP: Scottish Green Party co-leaders Patrick
Voices of Scotland / 19 November 2024
19 November 2024
STEPHEN LOW details how the Scottish Greens’ retreat from full opposition to the Bill gives the SNP the opportunity to revive this toxic legislation and push through privatisation under the cover of popular reforms
Campaigners gather outside the Scottish Parliament at Holyro
Voices of Scotland / 9 April 2024
9 April 2024
They have done it again, laments STEPHEN LOW, as the Scottish government passes another intrusive Act, this time on ‘hate crimes,’ that seems so unworkable even those announcing it could not describe it accurately
WHO CARES: Confusion reigns over plans for a national care s
Features / 27 February 2024
27 February 2024
What the SNP-Green administration is asking politicians to do by voting on the new care service legislation, without being clear on what it even is, totally undermines Holyrood, writes STEPHEN LOW
FRUITY BEHAVIOUR: Scottish Health Secretary Michael Matheson
Voices of Scotland / 27 November 2023
27 November 2023
What could have been easily explained away and apologised for has instead ballooned into an embarrassing cover-up scandal for the Scottish political scene, reports STEPHEN LOW
Similar stories
(2nd left to right) Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie, Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar and Davy Russell celebrate during a rally on Castle Street, Hamilton, after he was declared the winner for the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election. The by-election was triggered after the death of SNP minister Christina McKelvie, June 6, 2025
Scotland / 9 June 2025
9 June 2025

Voters are clearly increasingly fed up with the SNP, but Labour can’t just assume that they will reap the benefit – especially with an ascendant Reform UK waiting in the wings, says STEPHEN LOW

Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar speaks during the Labour
Features / 24 September 2024
24 September 2024
With a lack of radical thinking from the Starmer-led UK government, support for Scottish independence is unlikely to evaporate any time soon – spelling trouble ahead for Anas Sarwar, argues PAULINE BRYAN
Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar
Features / 29 August 2024
29 August 2024
Plans to change the law to give the Scottish Secretary of State powers to bypass the Scottish Parliament to directly fund ‘anti-poverty schemes’ could provoke an unwelcome crisis for Anas Sarwar, argues VINCE MILLS
PROMISING BEGINNING? Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar with
Features / 6 July 2024
6 July 2024
STEPHEN LOW looks at an election in Scotland that, for the first time in a decade, wasn’t a fight about flags