Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Spanish Civil War dud
JOHN GREEN is unimpressed by a novel that simply borrows the civil war as a backdrop
LIFTING SPIRITS: Members of La Barraca Republican mobile theatre group, 1933 - much like the one the protagonist might have joined...

Soldiers in the Fog
By Antonio Soler, The Clapton Press, £12.99

THIS Spanish Civil War novel was first published in 1999 in Spanish, under the title El Nombre Que Ahora Digo (The Name I Now Call Out) and was awarded the Premio Primavera de Novela.
 
It is, however, not a historical account of events that took place at that time, nor is it about the international brigades. It plunges us head first into the horror and squalor of war on a purely human level.

It is written in a lyrical prose style which certainly captures atmosphere and that sense of chaos that all wars engender. I felt, however, that the civil war is used here merely as a convenient backdrop for a human interest story and that the author has little interest in casting new light on that significant historical event nor whether he has an opinion on the rights and wrongs of that conflict.

The story is set during the Spanish Civil War, and is quite simple: a young soldier, Gustavo Sintora, arrives in Madrid after Franco’s rebel forces capture Malaga. He is posted to the Republican army’s mobile entertainment unit which is billeted in a mansion on the city’s outskirts and puts on shows for those fighting on the front line. In Madrid he meets Serena Vergara, a seamstress who is destined to become the love of his life.

As the war becomes darker and more intense, Sintora’s unit is sent into action on the Ebro front. Faced with the horrors of the battlefield and the inevitability of defeat, the unit gradually disintegrates, and the soldiers go their separate ways. Sintora rushes back to Madrid, desperate to find Serena.

To give a flavour of the novel’s politics or lack thereof, here are three instances that take place in the novel. Firstly, in one of the opening chapters the chief protagonist, the young private, Gustavo Sintora, arrives at a Russian army camp in Republican Spain. They were “blind drunk”, he writes, and there he witnesses how a Russian airman executes two of his compatriots in cold blood for alleged “treason.”

Second, Stalin is lampooned among the Republican soldiers, even though it is Stalin’s Russia providing the only aid to the Republic. And third, one of Sintora’s troupe is “a communist” who, as a sideline business, captures aristocrats or priests whom he then ransoms in order to stash away the cash so that he can survive in style after they are defeated and the war is over. Such things are unlikely to inspire a raw recruit like Sintora. 

The narrative is interwoven throughout with excerpts from Gustavo Sintora’s notebooks which, according to the story, he had handed over to the narrator’s father towards the end of the war. On the basis of these fictitious notebooks, the narrator has, as he says, “pieced together the story that took place many years before I was born... Sintora wasn’t thinking of any particular country or any particular army or even any particular flag. His true motherland was embodied in a woman,” the author writes. This sets the tone of the narrative.

Soler’s novel could, in essence, be about any conflict. The reader is provided with little context apart from the fact that it is clearly set in Spain and a war is going on. There is a general air of cynicism or detachment among the protagonists and a certainty of defeat pervades their outlook. The reader is none the wiser about what they are fighting for or whether they have or had any ideals or visions for a democratic Spain. The author merely paints a picture of human frailty in time of war and conveys its misery and senselessness and how it tears families, communities and relationships apart.

Not a book I would recommend to anyone who wishes to gain knowledge or deeper insights into the Spanish Civil War.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
fall
Book Review / 30 May 2025
30 May 2025

JOHN GREEN wades through a pessimistic prophesy that does not consider the need for radical change in political and social structures

CONTESTED HISTORY: The Neue Wache (“the New Watchhouse”) was rebuilt by the GDR in 1957 and reopened in 1960 as a Memorial to the Victims of Fascism and Militarism — then, in 1993, it was rededicated to the ‘victims of war and tyranny’
Features / 26 May 2025
26 May 2025

JOHN GREEN observes how Berlin’s transformation from socialist aspiration to imperial nostalgia mirrors Germany’s dangerous trajectory under Chancellor Merz — a BlackRock millionaire and anti-communist preparing for a new war with Russia

221
Film of the week / 1 May 2025
1 May 2025

JOHN GREEN recommends a German comedy that celebrates the old GDR values of solidarity, community and a society not dominated by consumerism

Mural depicting the symbol of the revolution - a soldier with a carnation in the barrel of his gun; People celebrating on top of a tank in Lisbon during the Carnation Revolution of April 25 1974 / Pics: IsmailKupeli/CC; Public domain
Books / 24 April 2025
24 April 2025

JOHN GREEN welcomes an insider account of the achievements and failures of the transition to democracy in Portugal

Similar stories
A unit of the Bulgarian International Brigade, 1937
Features / 25 January 2025
25 January 2025
Anti-fascists from around the world will soon be travelling to Spain to commemorate the International Brigades and walk in the footsteps of the bravest of their generation, writes LYNNE WALSH
The Mackenzie-Papineau Battalion monument, in Ottawa, rememb
Book Review / 22 July 2024
22 July 2024
JOHN GREEN suggests you pass on a novelette that recycles the communist past without hope or tangible history
NOT TO BE FORGOTTEN: Members of the British Battalion displa
Features / 29 June 2024
29 June 2024
Teaching youngsters about the International Brigades and the Spanish civil war is vital for a proper understanding of 20th-century history, writes JIM JUMP
WORKING CLASS HEROES: Detail from the mural tribute to the I
Features / 24 June 2024
24 June 2024
JIM JUMP welcomes the new booklet published by the RMT and International Brigade Memorial Trust about the seafarers and rail workers who fought Franco’s fascism in Spain