Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Outspoken Women: how campaigners for sex-based rights see their priorities under a new government
LYNNE WALSH reports on discussions among feminist campaigners and a recent Swansea University event
Caroline Ffiske of Women Uniting, Heather Binning from the Women's Rights Network and Maya Forstater of Sex Matters in Victoria Tower Gardens, Westminster

RECENT events have left women who fight for their sex-based rights in trepidation as to what will happen next.

Helen Joyce, director of advocacy at human rights charity Sex Matters, said after the election result: “We look forward to working to help Keir Starmer’s government strengthen sex-based rights in order to protect women and children.

“Labour has pledged to support a broad range of rights for women, but it will only be able to deliver if it has the courage to be clear that sex is real and that it matters.

“If the new government gives in under pressure to obfuscate sex-based language and data, its goals will be unachievable.

“It is blindingly clear that sex and gender cannot be dismissed as a fringe issue. Women’s sex-based rights came up repeatedly throughout the election campaign, while several polls showed strong support for protecting and strengthening them, right across the political spectrum.”

Earlier in the week, Joyce was speaking at an event in Swansea University, alongside Professor Jo Phoenix and Maya Forstater. All three are renowned gender critical campaigners. Joining them was employment barrister Akua Reindorf KC.

Reindorf said that conflicts between the Equality Act (EA) and the Gender Recognition Act (GRA) led to situations of Byzantine complexity.

The confusion is reflected in campaign group For Women Scotland’s current case, to be heard in the Supreme Court this November. They want “sex” to be clarified in the EA as “biological sex” and not “acquired gender.” They claim that the latter interpretation leaves the equality law “opaque and unworkable” for women.

Reindorf said: “The impact of the GRA on the EA is very far-reaching, and very, very confusing. My personal view is that it’s unsustainable. It has a very significant impact on sexual orientation discrimination, and arguably means that the categories of lesbian and gay man aren’t even sensible categories. Under the EA now, a lesbian is a biological woman, or a transwoman with a GRC (gender recognition certificate) who is attracted to biological women and to transwomen with GRCs — but not to transwomen without GRCs.”

Forstater responded that Sex Matters did not believe that a GRC changed biological sex, for the purpose of the EA. She wanted a focus on the EA, she said, “because that’s putting the focus on women’s rights.”

Their demand was for a section of the GRA to be repealed, so that in no longer claimed that sex could be changed “for all legal purposes.”

Joyce made the point that, during the election campaign, when someone asked a politician, “Why do you not care about women’s rights?” they responded by talking about “trans rights.”

What was needed, she said, was clarity, and offered the scenario, “This woman needs to have an internal vaginal exam, and she has said she is only willing to have it from a woman. This man has a piece of paper, saying he’s a woman. Does he have the right to walk in and stick his fingers in her vagina? We have to have an answer to that.”

The event, at the university’s Taliesin arts centre, drew a small number of protesters. At the time of going to press, police said that a 22-year-old woman had been arrested on suspicion of assault, though not yet charged, and on bail.

Swansea University boasts a code of practice setting out the conduct and procedures for anyone attending or organising activities and meetings on its premises.

It is a breach of the code to prevent or disrupt informal discussions based on the views or beliefs of participants, and to harass participants.

In February this year, a copy of Helen Joyce’s book Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality was removed from display in the library, after a single complaint.

At the time, women’s group Merched Cymru said: “We’ve had a couple of serious issues with gender activists staging threatening anti-women protests at events at the university, so we weren’t surprised when we heard a rumour that Trans had been removed from a library display. It’s just part of the pattern that we’ve come to expect from Swansea University.”

Several women and men at the event were relatively new to the issues. One woman told me: “I came with an open mind. I liked the fact this was put on by a group called Outspoken Women. I didn’t expect to see these protesters — what are they shouting about? I don’t think I really felt like an outspoken woman when I got here — but I will be, now!”

A man leaving the event stopped me, and asked: “Would you quote me? Just say I’m an elderly chap who believes in women, and in freedom of speech. What has struck me — apart from the eloquent speakers and the women who asked questions — is the bravery. You all ran the gauntlet, as if you were all so used to it. I’d like to shake every single one of you by the hand.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
Caroline Darian / Pic: Olivier Roller
Features / 6 June 2025
6 June 2025

Caroline Darian, daughter of Gisele Pelicot, took part in a conversation with Afua Hirsch at London’s Royal Geographical Society. LYNNE WALSH reports 

Demonstrators during an anti-racism protest organised by Sta
Antifascism / 7 May 2025
7 May 2025

This year’s Bristol Radical History Festival focused on the persistent threats of racism, xenophobia and, of course, our radical collective resistance to it across Ireland and Britain, reports LYNNE WALSH 

Lynne Walsh piece webpic.jpg
Features / 22 April 2025
22 April 2025

LYNNE WALSH previews the Bristol Radical History Conference this weekend

REMARKABLE: The Danish writer Karen Blixen as a recipient of
International Women's Day 2025 / 8 March 2025
8 March 2025
With most of recorded history dominated by the voices of men, LYNNE WALSH encourages sisters to read the memoirs of women – and to write their own too
Similar stories
The UK Supreme Court in Parliament Square, central London
Britain / 26 November 2024
26 November 2024
Features / 17 November 2024
17 November 2024
From prostitution to surrogacy, access to women’s bodies can be bought for a fee. LYNNE WALSH reports from a conference exploring the mounting crisis in which women are increasingly seen as products to be consumed
Opinion / 28 June 2024
28 June 2024
Labour Women’s Declaration responds to Labour’s 2024 manifesto