Skip to main content
Advertise Buy the paper Contact us Shop Subscribe Support us
Metaphorical over-reach
JOHN GREEN is frustrated by an ambitious novel that stretches the imagination to breaking point

There Are Rivers in the Sky 
Elif Shafak, Viking, £18.99

RAINDROPS as metaphor for historical memory is a clever narrative device that Shafak exploits to the full, taking us from ancient Mesopotamia, via the British Museum in Victorian Britain to modern-day Turkey, where a young Yazidi girl is reminded by her grandmother of the ancient history of their country in which the Yazidis are still a persecuted minority. 

Melding fiction with real historical events and figures, Shafak creates a fascinating story that intertwines individual lives with historical events, involving class, race and colonialism. 

The novel begins in ancient Mesopotamia, when a raindrop falls on the head of despotic ruler Ashurbanipal. He owns an extraordinary library of clay tablets which includes the Epic poem of Gilgamesh. We fast forward to mid-Victorian London, where the raindrop becomes a snowflake, settling on Arthur Smyth — also based on a real historical figure — as he is born in midwinter to a destitute mother on the banks of the Thames. The Victorian Assyriologist George Smith was indeed a self-taught working-class boy who became an expert in the interpretation of ancient cuneiform writing, but Shafak’s retelling of his life turns it into a fairy-tale, undermining its validity as a perceptive commentary on class. 

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Best of 2024 / 3 January 2025
3 January 2025
A landmark work of gay ethnography, an avant-garde fusion of folk and modernity, and a chance comment in a great interview
Theatre review / 29 November 2024
29 November 2024
ANGUS REID applauds the inventive stagecraft with which the Lyceum serve up Stevenson’s classic, but misses the deeper themes
Gig Review / 6 October 2024
6 October 2024
ANGUS REID time-travels back to times when Gay Liberation was radical and allied seamlessly to an anti-racist, anti-establishment movement
Interview / 15 March 2024
15 March 2024
ANGUS REID speaks to historian Siphokazi Magadla about the women who fought apartheid and their impact on South African society
Similar stories
Theatre review / 21 October 2024
21 October 2024
DAVID NICHOLSON is disappointed that an ambitious telling of the strike from a Welsh perspective disregards the collective struggle
Books / 6 August 2024
6 August 2024
GORDON PARSONS welcomes a graphic biography of George Sand, the most popular French novelist in 19th-century Britain
Book Review / 5 June 2024
5 June 2024
ALEX HALL asks whether ‘western civilisation’ is simply a disruptive polarisation in what was historically a diverse and interconnected world