Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
It’ll take more than rhetoric to reverse the Tories’ pay cap
Scotland’s workers can’t rely on the SNP to bring about a real change in pay policy, writes LYNN HENDERSON

ALMOST ten years since the crisis of economic greed, ordinary public-sector workers continue to pay the price of bailing out the bankers through wages slashed, cut, frozen and capped.

What a terrible way to treat the people who keep this country running. People that look after our courts, jobcentres, tax offices, schools, hospitals, driving centres, museums, galleries, passport offices, coastguard centres, fire and police stations and borders have seen their standards of living slip.

The services they deliver are run down. Only commitment to the public good drives these workers on.

Squeezed, frozen and capped below inflation, the pay of public-sector workers is now a public crisis.

When Theresa May talks about the “just-about-managing,” she probably didn’t even think that she was describing her own workforce.

The staff of government offices, processing centres and outposts across these islands have borne the brunt of austerity. They are the people whose pay the Prime Minister’s government sets.

From 2010 to 2016, average Civil Service pay fell by between £2,000 and £3,500 in real terms — a larger decline than the rest of the public sector and the wider economy.

With current pay capped at 1 per cent and inflation at 3.9 per cent and rising, members of the Public and Commercial Services Union (PCS) are angry.

No longer willing to just-about-manage, thousands have sent their pay calculations to tell Philip Hammond just how much their pay has fallen.

Payday protests have been growing across government offices on the last day of every month. And today many more workers will mass outside their workplaces.

United in demanding an end to the pay cap, workers will also highlight the multiplied total lost to the local economy because of government pay policy.

Hundreds of thousands of pounds not spent in local shops, restaurants, hairdressers and culture and leisure facilities because people are struggling to just-about-manage.

It is startlingly obvious that holding down public-sector pay is counterproductive, unjust and economically unnecessary.

Yet still, both Chancellor and Cabinet Secretary Damian Green dismiss and contemptuously deny the serious impact of ever downward spiralling pay, cuts to pensions and cuts to redundancy rights.

Well, that’s the Tories for you. What then of the SNP Scottish government?

The Scottish TUC point out that Scottish government pay policy impacts on the pay of 90 per cent of Scottish public-sector workers.

Half a million workers are dependent on the SNP government taking action now for a fair pay deal.

Both Nicola Sturgeon and her Finance Minister Derek Mackay say they will end the pay cap in 2018. Yet, they will not fund above-inflation pay rises for their own workforce, who are suffering right now.

Saying you will end the cap, but not use your tax powers to redistribute wealth rings hollow. Without actual money in actual pockets of actual workers, the SNP government’s position is just empty rhetoric.

Where then is the alternative? Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn and shadow chancellor John McDonnell are clear. They support a return to above-inflation pay rises for public-sector workers, funded through real investment in public services.

Closer to home, both candidates for Scottish Labour leader have said they want to end the pay cap. Only Richard Leonard, however offers any suggestion of real change to make this happen.

In his Workers’ Manifesto, Leonard, like Corbyn and McDonnell, challenges the economic orthodoxy, but not just by modest tinkering.

The real change offered by Leonard is a real commitment to public ownership and wealth redistribution. Anas Sarwar, like the SNP and previous Labour governments, offers timidity on taxation that is simply not enough.

The Tory Budget later in November is likely to be more of the same denial that workers deserve a pay rise. This will not do.

Workers however do not exercise their power through waiting on a kinder set of politicians to present them with handout policies.

Only workers can act to bring about the change in pay policy.

From October 9 until November 6, the Public and Commercial Services Union (PCS) is undergoing a national ballot of all Civil Service members on pay.

The PCS ballot is not an end in itself. It is the beginning of an ambitious pay campaign, to rebuild confidence across the public-sector workforce that by standing together they can win again.

Like Corbyn, McDonnell and Leonard, we believe that all public-sector workers deserve a pay rise now!

Lynn Henderson is PCS national officer for Scotland and Ireland and vice-president of the STUC.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
VOICES OF SCOTLAND / 30 December 2024
30 December 2024
With new faces being elected to both to government and to my union, PCS, 2024 has been a year of change – with new challenges ahead for 2025, writes LYNN HENDERSON
Members of the PCS union on the picket line outside the Pass
VOICES OF SCOTLAND / 30 October 2023
30 October 2023
In my union PCS, we know from experience that women are the first line of defence during this ongoing period of attacks from the government and employers on our living standards, writes LYNN HENDERSON
NEW MOOD: Passport Office workers picket in Glasgow, April 3
VOICES OF SCOTLAND / 24 April 2023
24 April 2023
PCS senior national officer LYNN HENDERSON explains why the union is growing and taking more industrial action despite the hostility of the current government to workers’ demands
Voices of Scotland / 11 October 2022
11 October 2022
With PCS members themselves facing poverty due to poor pay and the cost-of-living crisis, industrial action was inevitable — it’s time to link up our struggles, writes LYNN HENDERSON
Similar stories
SPEAKING OUT: PCS president Fran Heathcote
International Women's Day 2025 / 8 March 2025
8 March 2025
As the government ploughs ahead with £3 billion in welfare cuts, arbitrary office-return mandates, and below-inflation pay rises, women will bear the brunt through deepening poverty and increased caring burdens, argues FRAN HEATHCOTE
VOICES OF SCOTLAND / 30 December 2024
30 December 2024
With new faces being elected to both to government and to my union, PCS, 2024 has been a year of change – with new challenges ahead for 2025, writes LYNN HENDERSON
TUC Congress 2024 / 7 September 2024
7 September 2024
There is no stronger economy without the stronger wages that provide extra disposable income, which is why workers – including civil servants – must have their pay boosted in real terms, along with restored union rights and insourcing, says FRAN HEATHCOTE