Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
The end of dialogue
SIMON PARSONS applauds an assured and enjoyable adaptation of Ali Smith’s meditative and pessimistic novel about Brexit Britain
Rebecca Banatvala in Harry MacDonald's adaptation of Autumn

Autumn
The North Wall Arts Centre, Oxford

ALI SMITH’s 2017 Booker Prize short-listed novel was regarded as one of the first post-Brexit works dealing with the ramifications of the previous year’s European Union membership referendum.

Its depiction of an increasingly insular and fearful country, set on erecting fences while petty, pedantic officialdom flourishes has proved remarkably prescient.

Harry McDonald’s timely adaptation of the novel remains essentially true to Smith’s work revelling in the nature of words, but has even broader implications now with nationalistic European movements growing ever stronger and the re-election of Donald Trump, with his alarmingly hostile and isolationist agenda. 

With a light and engagingly whimsical touch, this changing world view is seen over 20 years through the eyes of a maturing Elisabeth and the inspirational relationship with her elderly childhood neighbour, Daniel. 

Charlotte Vickers’ assured and enjoyable production has a critically inquisitive Elisabeth, played with warmth and good humour by Rebecca Banatvala, enthused by Gary Lilburn’s charismatic Daniel and his playful discussions on books, language and art. 

Not quite as effective is Daniel’s final dream-like sequence from his care home bed. Profound elements relating to the cyclical nature of history and his Jewish sister’s wartime arrest in France contend with more contrived moments such as Banatvala donning a wig to become Pauline Boty, a ’60s British pop artist and significant figure for both Daniel and Elisabeth.

Sophie Ward as Elisabeth’s inexplicably detached mother develops but still remains a shallow if appealing depiction compared to the complexity of the main characters, while Nancy Crane’s stereotypical roles as various bureaucratic officials, garners humour while sign-posting the way Smith judges society to be heading towards “the end of dialogue.”

Run ended.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
Similar stories
Lizzie Watts and Andre Squire in Jane Upton’s (the) Woman
Theatre review / 19 February 2025
19 February 2025
SIMON PARSONS is discomfited by an unflichingly negative portrait of motherhood and its trials
Hiba Medina as Antiya in Antigone (On Strike) 
Theatre Review / 4 February 2025
4 February 2025
SIMON PARSONS applauds a tense and thoughtful production that regularly challenges our political engagement and prejudices
COMPLEX INNER LIVES: The cast of The Lonely Londoners
Theatre Review / 20 January 2025
20 January 2025
MARY CONWAY applauds a brilliant theatrical adaptation of Sam Selvon’s classic 1950s novel of oppression, betrayal and resilience
PINKIE PROMISE: Nell Barlow and Amelie Abbott in Never Let M
Theatre Review / 7 November 2024
7 November 2024
SIMON PARSONS applauds a moving version of Ishiguro’s vision of a world in which science and ethics have diverged