Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Something might come of Nothing
MARIA DUARTE sees an unusual film about the class consciousness that develops among a group of Lisbon workers faced with the destruction of their livelihoods

The Nothing Factory
Directed by Pedro Pinho

 

IN THE Nothing Factory, a group of Portuguese workers stage their own mini-revolt in a fight to stop their lift factory from closing and save their jobs in what's a surreal portrait of work in modern times.

 

Exploring the impact of the economic crisis on working class people and the failure of capitalism, the workers break into song in this documentary-style drama which blurs the lines between reality and fiction.

 

The film opens with workers being called in the middle of the night to their factory in Lisbon to discover that their bosses are stealing the machinery and raw materials before they shut it down.

 

To stop any further asset stripping, the workforce stage a sit-in, but their unity is soon tested when their employer offers them each a substantial lump-sum pay-off which sparks major tension and friction amongst the staff.

 

The suggestion by the firm's HR manager that they should see their redundancy as an opportunity adds insult to injury and the way she clandestinely approaches one of the men's wives in her workplace to get her to persuade her husband to accept the redundancy pay, underhand and despicable though it may be, is clever nonetheless.

 

When an Argentinian documentary film-maker arrives to make a film about their plight and suggests that they should run the factory themselves and be trailblazers, they quickly make the point that all they want to do is carry on working and be able to feed and clothe their families.

 

With a predominantly non-professional cast who deliver intense and heartfelt performances, Pinho's film is reminiscent of Ken Loach's before it veers off into a “neorealist musical,” as one of the characters describes it.
 

There's also an overly long in-depth dinner discussion about the adverse effects of capitalism in the middle of the film which had two audience members making a rapid exit when I saw it.


The three-hour running time of Pedro Pinho's feature film debut is certainly a challenge, but, if you manage to stay until the bitter end, this bizarre but ingeniously parable about workers' rights in Portugal has its rewards.


I can't help feeling that less would have been more, though.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
fotw
Film of the week / 5 June 2025
5 June 2025

MARIA DUARTE recommends an exposure of the state violence used against pro-Palestine protests in the US

round up
Cinema / 29 May 2025
29 May 2025

The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Along Came Love, The Ballad of Wallis Island, The Ritual, and Karate Kid: Legends

fotw
Film of the Week / 29 May 2025
29 May 2025

MARIA DUARTE recommends the powerful dramatisation of the true story of a husband and wife made homeless

IMPECCABLE: Benicio Del Toro as  Zsa-zsa Korda and Mia Threapleton as his daughter Liesl in The Phoenician Scheme
Film of the week / 22 May 2025
22 May 2025

MARIA DUARTE is in two minds about a peculiar latest offering from Wes Anderson

Similar stories
Firefox ridden by Sam Ewing on their way to winning the Mong
Horse racing / 12 March 2025
12 March 2025
Joyeuse ridden by James Bowen (left) passes Tutti Quanti rid
Horse racing / 8 February 2025
8 February 2025
Our tipster gives this weekend's lowdown
Calandagan ridden by Stephane Pasquier on their way to winni
Horse racing / 19 October 2024
19 October 2024
Our tipster looks at the best offerings from Ascot, York
End Zone ridden by jockey Callum Rodriguez on their way to w
Horse racing / 22 June 2024
22 June 2024
This week Farringdon looks at the final day of Ascot, as well as races in Newmarket and Haydock Park