Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
From Peterloo to Palestine: don’t criticise what you can’t understand

The government cracking down on something it can’t comprehend and doesn’t want to engage with is a repeating pattern of history, says KEITH FLETT

Police officers watch as people take part in a national march for Palestine on Whitehall in central London, January 18, 2025

THE government is cracking down on dissent and trying to criminalise it. Whether its investigating Bob Vylan and Kneecap for alleged criminal offences at Glastonbury, prosecuting some of those involved with a January 18 2025 central London march on Palestine and now banning the peaceful direct-action campaigners Palestine Action as “terrorists.”

Whatever words Labour politicians may use the aim is clearly to delegitimise opposition to Israel’s genocide in Gaza and to make people fearful of the consequences of protesting.

It’s not a unique situation. In fact the template was set by a peaceful protest for the vote in central Manchester on August 16 1819. It was not peaceful on the side of the state, however, as the yeomanry, men on horseback, cut down, killed and injured protesters.

The reason, in hindsight, is clear. While the government was used to gatherings of people for fairs and other social events, it was faced with a mass political demonstration. There was no conception as to what might happen, but the fear was of violence and revolt.

The chair of the bench that committed the sole speaker at Peterloo, Henry Hunt, for trial said: “Assembled, with such insignia and in such a manner, with the black flag, the bloody dagger with ‘equal representation or death’ … they came in a threatening manner, they came under the banners of death, thereby showing they meant to overturn the government.”

Except the Peterloo protesters were not a death cult, they simply wanted the democratic right to vote. The banners and words were rhetoric not an intent of revolution.

The government then went further: one of the six Acts, which were actually formally passed in December 1819, was the Seditious Meetings Act.

Under the Act all meetings of more than 50 people — in reality no more than 49 persons — were allowed. This included any meeting “for the purpose … of deliberating upon any public grievance, or upon any matter or thing relating to any trade, manufacture, business, or profession, or upon any matter in church or state.” The only exception were meetings called by an “authorised official.”

In addition a meeting of people in one specific area could be called provided permission was given by a justice of the peace. He of course required six days’ notice. At such meetings no banners, flags or emblems of any sort were allowed.

While the Act was repealed in 1824, a related limit of no more than 49 delegates at any representative gathering remained in place through the Chartist period up to 1848.

In order to try to avoid official interference in protest meetings, these were often held out of town in remote rural spots well away from the reach of the authorities.

The pattern of the government cracking down on something it can’t comprehend and doesn’t want to engage with is repeated in 2025.

A Times editorial after Glastonbury, noting that the crowd for Bob Vylan had joined in with the cry to “Death to the IDF,” suggested that clearly most of them did not understand what they were apparently agreeing with. Why, in the view of the Times, would people want to see the end of an armed force that was busy pursuing a genocide? It could not understand.

The popular movements that developed after Peterloo from trade unionism to Chartism were successful in reclaiming the ability to democratically organise and protest. The government continued to attack industrial disputes, but it was exceptional for a political demonstration to be attacked.

That surely is a lesson for today — to keep on keepin’ on, having in mind the words of the other Bob — Dylan — who sang in the Times They Are Changin’ “don’t criticise what you can’t understand.”

Keith Flett is a socialist historian.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Prime Minister Tony Blair welcomes American President George W Bush to the first meeting of the G8 Summit at the Gleneagles Hotel in Scotland, July 7, 2005
Features / 26 June 2025
26 June 2025

While Hardie, MacDonald and Wilson faced down war pressure from their own Establishment, today’s leadership appears to have forgotten that opposing imperial adventures has historically defined Labour’s moral authority, writes KEITH FLETT

Former Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn speaking at the People's Assembly Against Austerity protest in central London, June 7, 2025
Labour’s loss / 12 June 2025
12 June 2025

10 years ago this month, Corbyn saved Labour from its right-wing problem, and then the party machine turned on him. But all is not lost yet for the left, says KEITH FLETT

WINNING OVER THE WORKING CLASS? Margaret Thatcher (left) personally sells off a London council house in her bid to undermine the welfare state and woo Labour voters via the 1980 Housing Act and so-called ‘right to buy’ for tenants
Features / 26 May 2025
26 May 2025

Research shows Farage mainly gets rebel voters from the Tory base and Labour loses voters to the Greens and Lib Dems — but this doesn’t mean the danger from the right isn’t real, explains historian KEITH FLETT

Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch at their local election campaign launch at The Curzon Centre in Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, March 20, 2025
Features / 14 May 2025
14 May 2025

KEITH FLETT traces how the ‘world’s most successful political party’ has imploded since Thatcher’s fall, from nine leaders in 30 years to losing all 16 English councils, with Reform UK symbolically capturing Peel’s birthplace, Tamworth — but the beast is not dead yet

Similar stories
Previously unissued photo dated 28/6/2025 of Bob Vylan crowd surfs during his performance on the West Holts Stage, during the Glastonbury Festival at Worthy Farm in Somerset. The performer led crowds on the festival's West Holts Stage in chants of
Media / 2 July 2025
2 July 2025

Despite declining to show Kneecap’s set, the BBC broadcast Bob Vylan leading a ‘death to the IDF’ chant — and the resulting outrage has only amplified the very message the Establishment wanted silenced, writes LINDA PENTZ GUNTER

Kneecap performing on the West Holts Stage during the Glastonbury Festival at Worthy Farm in Somerset, June 28, 2025
Britain / 29 June 2025
29 June 2025

BBC accused of silencing acts at Glastonbury for standing in solidarity with Palestine

A cartoon depiction of the arrest of the Cato Street Conspir
Features / 4 February 2025
4 February 2025
The legacy of an 1820 conspiracy in revenge for Peterloo resonates down the ages, argues KEITH FLETT
REACTIONARY RAMPAGE:
The house of radical dissenter
Joseph P
Features / 19 August 2024
19 August 2024
Socialist historian KEITH FLETT traces the parallel evolution of violent loyalist rampages and the workers' movement's peaceful democratic crowds, highlighting the stark contrast between recent far-right thuggery and mass Gaza protests