Skip to main content
Cultural resistance

GEORGE FOGARTY is stunned by the epic and life-affirming sound of an outstanding Palestinian musical collective

STEADFAST: Hamza Arnaout, Tareq Abu Kwaik and Ramzy Suleiman of the Shamstep Palestinian musical collective 47Soul / Pic: George Fogarty

47Soul
Scala, London
★★★★★

“CAN you dance while you shoot?” asked Israeli dance music icon Noga Erez back in 2017. Erez - who, like nearly all Israelis, served three years in the occupation forces - appeared to be asking her listeners whether it is ethical - or even possible - to enjoy yourself whilst enforcing a violent occupation. Ample social media posts from IDF soldiers since then have answered the question in the affirmative, and Erez no longer seems to bother herself with such questions.

The question for Palestinians, especially of the diaspora, and their supporters is rather different: can you dance whilst your nation is being exterminated?

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
TOMORROW'S WARRIOR: Nubya Garcia
Live Music Review / 19 March 2025
19 March 2025
GEORGE FOGARTY is mesmerised by the messages made when jazz is played by people who grew up steeped in jungle and hip-hop
LYCANTHROPIC STAND UP: Stewart Lee vs The ManWulf
Comedy / 10 February 2025
10 February 2025
GEORGE FOGARTY applauds a show that punches down alt-right-friendly comedy
Aja Monet
Interview / 9 October 2024
9 October 2024
George Fogarty speaks to US Surrealist Blues poet AJA MONET
MUSIC FOR OUR TIMES: Disraeli leads the singing at Edinburgh
Gig Review / 30 May 2024
30 May 2024
This is music that brings the party, the catharsis and the love all at once, says GEORGE FOGARTY 
Similar stories
round up
Cinema / 1 May 2025
1 May 2025

Borrowed Time: Lennon’s Last Decade, Parthenope, Where Dragons Live and Thunderbolts* reviewed by MICHAL BONCZA and MARIA DUARTE

Treading Water / Pic: IMDb
Film of the week / 24 April 2025
24 April 2025

MARIA DUARTE recommends a tough love story that unfolds among mental health issues, drug addiction and inadequate housing

Shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick. Photo: Lucy North/PA
Tory party / 23 April 2025
23 April 2025

Badenoch under pressure to sack shadow justice secretary

IS albums
Album reviews / 21 April 2025
21 April 2025

New releases from Brown Horse, Craig Finn, and Julien Baker & TORRES