STEVEN ANDREW is moved beyond words by a historical account of mining in Britain made from the words of the miners themselves
GEORGE FOGARTY is stunned by the epic and life-affirming sound of an outstanding Palestinian musical collective

47Soul
Scala, London
★★★★★
“CAN you dance while you shoot?” asked Israeli dance music icon Noga Erez back in 2017. Erez - who, like nearly all Israelis, served three years in the occupation forces - appeared to be asking her listeners whether it is ethical - or even possible - to enjoy yourself whilst enforcing a violent occupation. Ample social media posts from IDF soldiers since then have answered the question in the affirmative, and Erez no longer seems to bother herself with such questions.
The question for Palestinians, especially of the diaspora, and their supporters is rather different: can you dance whilst your nation is being exterminated?



