Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
High Court rules disabled benefit delays are unlawful

IAIN DUNCAN SMITH fell foul of the courts yet again yesterday when a judge ruled that delays paying new benefits to two disabled claimants were both “unacceptable” and “unlawful.”

The High Court was told at a recent hearing that vulnerable people had been forced to turn to loan sharks and foodbanks due to delays in providing them with the personal independence payment (PIP).

PIP is designed to help disabled adults meet the extra costs caused by disability and is replacing the disability living allowance (DLA) as part of the Tories’ overhaul of the benefits system.

Claimants dubbed Ms C and Mr W asked Ms Justice Patterson to declare that, because of the magnitude of the delay, Work and Pensions Secretary Mr Duncan Smith breached his common law and human rights duties to make payments within a reasonable time.

In Ms C’s case payment was delayed from September 9 2013 until the determination of her benefit on October 24 2014.

In Mr W’s case the delay was some 10 months, from February 3 2014 until December 2014.

Mrs Justice Patterson said both cases had called for “expeditious consideration” as they both suffered significant disabilities.

“They were each to be regarded as the most vulnerable people in society,” she said.

In each case, she found that the delay was “not only unacceptable, as conceded by the defendant, but was unlawful.”

Richard Kramer of the national deafblind charity Sense said: “The legal ruling gives a human face to the significant levels of stress and suffering felt by disabled people as a result of system delays.

“The case is a reminder that there is some way to go before the system can be regarded as fit for purpose and customer-facing for all disabled people.”

Responding to the ruling, public-sector union PCS general secretary Mark Serwotka said: “We pay tribute to the claimants but they should never have had to resort to the courts.

“Cases like this expose Iain Duncan Smith’s brutal, unforgiving and suspicious attitude to people who rely on social security and the failure of privatisation to offer the kind of help and support DWP staff want to provide.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Britain / 24 March 2017
24 March 2017
Anti-racist and faith groups lead vigil for terrorist attack victims
Britain / 24 March 2017
24 March 2017
Britain / 11 March 2017
11 March 2017
Britain / 11 March 2017
11 March 2017
Similar stories
WE WANT TO WORK: Disability activists protest previous welfa
Features / 20 March 2025
20 March 2025
By making Personal Independence Payments harder to access, Labour is creating another barrier for those already struggling with soaring care costs, workplace discrimination and prejudiced employers, argues RUTH HUNT
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall outside Downing Stre
Features / 13 March 2025
13 March 2025
Both Conservative and Labour administrations have now refused to release research showing PIP payments are vital for disabled people’s survival, exposing the ideological nature of planned welfare ‘reforms,’ writes Dr DYLAN MURPHY